The-turing-way: On paper review process

[malvikasharan]

Detailed description

• This issue is a place to discuss matters relating to the writing of the chapter on _reviewing_

Resources

• This post by Rene Bekker: https://renebekkers.wordpress.com/2020/06/24/how-to-review-a-paper/
  
  
  
  • Twitter thread: https://twitter.com/renebekkers/status/1275724073297985540?s=20
  
  

Discussion points/related issues

• Open for anyone to take and adapt for the chapter

Current status

This chapter is empty. If anyone would like to make a start they are more than welcome to do so.

• [ ] Write chapter outline
• [ ] Add material to the chapter
• [ ] Combine materials into a readable chapter
• [ ] Proofread
• [ ] Request reviews
• [ ] Address reviews
• [ ] Merge to master branch.

Updates

[malvikasharan]

More resources to mention:

• Prereview: https://t.co/GDns1IUHiJ?amp=1
• Advice on research and writing: https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~jac22/advice.html
• Suereview blog series:
  
  
  
  • dart.ed.ac.uk/june-blogs
  
  
  • http://dart.ed.ac.uk/start-new-project
  
  
  • http://dart.ed.ac.uk/how-to-finish-a-project
  
  
  • http://dart.ed.ac.uk/poster-perfect
  
  

Twitter thread by Kirstie: https://twitter.com/kirstie_j/status/1275688758097129481?s=20

[Ismael-KG]

I wonder if Heesen and Bright's (2020) paper against prepublication peer reviews is a useful resource?

• https://academic.oup.com/bjps/article/doi/10.1093/bjps/axz029/5526887

[malvikasharan]

Hey @karvovskaya
, here is the issue we discussed.

[Karvovskaya]

I will start working here: https://hackmd.io/cg2uL01nSd6TVrjxHU5c2A Once I have a draft I will ask someone to review :-)

[Ismael-KG]

@BrainonSilicon, @LauraCarter and Ana Basiri and I just had a really interesting chat about everything peer review and we returned to this issue to see how it's going. @Karvovskaya have you put some ideas together on that hackmd? (The link isn't working for me!). We would love to see.

There's also a lot around the work in Living With Machines at the Turing: https://livingwithmachines.ac.uk/highlighting-authors-contributions-and-interdisciplinary-collaborations-in-living-with-machines/ (yet to discuss with @fedenanni!)