Secret-hitler: Make it so game doesn't allow fas to shoot hitler

[DennisTheFinn]

will help prevent trolls and people who do it on accident

[cozuya]

@jbasrai I think we had some discussion about this and we decided against?

[jbasrai]

Yeah, there's no rule against it, so I don't think it should be enforced by the game engine.

[cozuya]

Actually this is a perfect item to be logged in (#161).

[jbasrai]

Agreed!

[DennisTheFinn]

hmm, interesting conclusion to this issue-- the only outcome to Hitler being shot by a fas is a clear troll or someone doing it 'on accident' and I feel that even though there is no rule against it, thinking about the issue logically leads me to believe that it would make sense to enforce the 'fas can't shoot Hitler' as it is something that should just be understood (leaving this option open allows trolls to ruin games easily). But if that is your conclusion then so be it :)

[jbasrai]

I think about it more of a separation of concerns. If the game decides to enforce things like this, then it makes it feel heavier and less fluid. In a dark future, when a Liberal draws 2r1b the game discards a red for him or investigating another Liberal makes the claim automatically. Might make sense from a pure strategy standpoint, but I view it as watering down the game and making it feel less fluid.

[cozuya]

I agree with the above post and yeah it means less work for devs :p If accidental executions are an issue we could always put in a confirmation box. Would that be a good solution?

[InvidiaSH]

Honestly it doesn't make sense for a fascist to be able to shoot Hitler, should be implemented.

[DennisTheFinn]

so dennis won?

[cozuya]

The polls won obv!

[DennisTheFinn]

sure....