Openstreetmap-carto: icon not placed inside polygon

[polarbearing]

As mentioned in the discussion of #2428, I have a parking P icon rendered outside the polygon, so it appears the parking would be in the building, where it is not.

Whether a mapnik issue or not,
@pnorman found it worth a ticket, and @math1985 commented Nov 19:

Hmm, it sees the relevant code on our side does contain ' marker-placement: interior;'. Is somebody able to create a mimimal example (minimal db and minimal cartocss/xml) to definitely prove it's not a problem on our side?

[pnorman]

A starting place would be to take the way/454480657/full XML and import it into the DB to render it.

[kocio-pl]

Most probably this is a Mapnik problem, which is fixed in 3.0.16 - duplicate of #1465.

[polarbearing]

Not fixed in the example in the first post. Is 3.0.16 already deployed?

[kocio-pl]

In the case of OSM.org, we have to wait until Mapnik 3.0.18 is released and packaged for Ubuntu, then for the OSMF server admins to deploy this package, so yes - the result is still not visible there.

However that's the problem outside the osm-carto code - if you deploy proper Mapnik version on your server, you will get proper placement of icons and labels.

[kocio-pl]

Using 3.0.18-rc1 it's really fixed: