Darktable: Grey theme: improve contrast, feedback request

Created on 26 Aug 2020  路  6Comments  路  Source: darktable-org/darktable

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

I have read quite some feedback in different places about the contrast of grey theme. Of course, having an important contrast on a grey theme is not possible, not as we can on a dark one. But maybe, we could improve a little bit more the grey theme contrast.

As we can't change grey on the UI, or we will lost the goal of this theme (near a grey theme and having better contrast possible), the only way is to update text color.

Describe the solution you'd like

I have tested two solutions to improve it by updating those lines (could be tested in preferences):

    @define-color fg_color @grey_95;
    @define-color plugin_fg_color @fg_color;
    @define-color section_label @grey_85;
    @define-color plugin_label_color @grey_85;
    @define-color bauhaus_fg @fg_color;
    @define-color fg_color @grey_100;
    @define-color plugin_fg_color @fg_color;
    @define-color section_label @grey_90;
    @define-color plugin_label_color @grey_90;
    @define-color bauhaus_fg @fg_color;

As you can see, it's only about increasing to 5% to the white the text on first one, and 10% on second in regard of actual grey theme.

Don't ask me why but I always had difficulties to apply a grey_100 (so pure white) on main text in any theme. Maybe personal aesthetics considerations or feeling about the global aspect of the theme. That's why I don't increase it before. But with time, maybe one of those proposals would be better.

Alternatives
No alternative asked here, just the text and which white to choose.

I would like to have some feedback about those proposals and if we keep the white as it is on actual theme or update to first or second proposal here. @johnny-bit, @elstoc, @Mark-64, @aurelienpierre, @rawfiner and @TurboGit: your feedback is welcomed.

Additional context

Most helpful comment

I prefer the actual theme, or something in between the actual theme and the first proposal like this (I find the module name of focused module too bright otherwise):

@define-color fg_color @grey_95;
@define-color plugin_fg_color @fg_color;
@define-color bauhaus_fg @fg_color;

All 6 comments

I am not the most indicated person to give a feedback here, as I don't use the grey theme, but the dark one. I know the disadvantage, but I simply can't stand the low contrast.
The first proposal is slighlty more contrasted and the second even more.
I would vote for the second, which doesn't mean I would start to use it ;-)

Honestly I've never really had a problem with the contrast of the grey themes. I prefer the first, which is perhaps marginally better than the current theme. I think the second one is a bit too contrasty for me. It's all just a matter of taste though really.

It's IMO good, depending on preferences of one checking. I've checked with fg_color to gray_100 and 95 one... I prefer the 95 one but then I don't have problem with low contrast ;) grey_100 looks a bit too harsh imo.

I prefer the actual theme, or something in between the actual theme and the first proposal like this (I find the module name of focused module too bright otherwise):

@define-color fg_color @grey_95;
@define-color plugin_fg_color @fg_color;
@define-color bauhaus_fg @fg_color;

Thanks for your comments. I agree that second one is too harsh. I like your proposal @rawfiner, much better. Will wait a little to see if other feedback coming but at this time your proposal seems the better choice.

+1 from me too for @rawfiner changes. It's much clearer what's ON now, but not too bright.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

sboukortt picture sboukortt  路  3Comments

lapineige picture lapineige  路  4Comments

elstoc picture elstoc  路  4Comments

schwerdf picture schwerdf  路  4Comments

ChristopherRogers1991 picture ChristopherRogers1991  路  6Comments