Per UX, the add-on rating stars should be yellow whenever they indicate the site user's personal rating. They should be gray in all other cases (for example: cumulative ratings in add-on listings).
Consult the UX specs before implementing. The spec currently looks like:

The current ratings use svg files for display, specifically:
All of which are found in /src/ui/components/Rating/img
I assume we'll need some new images for the gold stars? Who might be able to produce those?
So @kumar303 was kind enough to show me how to extract the gold outlined star from the sketch file, but I think we also need a full gold star. I assume we don't need a gold half-star, as gold is only used for the UI when a user can set a rating, and users cannot set half-star ratings. But I imagine that the UI would show all outlined stars if a user has not provided a rating, and then once they have rated an add-on we would show filled in gold stars to indicate their rating.
Are those assumptions correct @pwalm?
Verified as fixed on AMO-dev, FF58 (Win10, Android 7.0)
Interactive stars are now yellow:



Please consider using a different tone of yellow. My gut reaction is to not touch the rating widget 馃構, it pierces your eyes on the white background.
Here's a yellow that is more pleasant in my opinion.

@dessant Thanks for your feedback, but we have a design system in place that unifies things like colour, so we are unable to change that.
there is still confusing implementation of the star colour
Most helpful comment
Verified as fixed on AMO-dev, FF58 (Win10, Android 7.0)
Interactive stars are now yellow:


