Zwavejs2mqtt: FDG211: Scene notification not working and not published to either zwave or MQTT

[daballiemo]

Version

Build/Run method

• [ X] Docker
• [ ] PKG
• [ ] Manually built (git clone - npm install - npm run build )

zwavejs2mqtt version: 1.3.0
zwavejs version: 6.4.0

Describe the bug

The FIBARO FDG211 has scene capabilities, as an example: when pressing one of the buttons 2/3 times quickly after eachother will generate a scene event being transmitted. This works with HA 2021.1.5 and the zwave integration

To Reproduce

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Double or tripple click either button
2. No respons at all

Expected behavior

Node will generate scene in zwave so detection and usage is possible.

zwavejs_1.log

Additional info

Also see https://github.com/zwave-js/zwavejs2mqtt/issues/471

[daballiemo]

Made a new zwave.log from start, then click twice on the switch that has a light fitted and then twice on the switch without light (my "scene" switch).
zwavejs_1.log

[bdbogjoe]

but did you run using master branch of zwavejs ?

some commit in master branch are not yet released

[AlCalzone]

@daballiemo your log does not indicate that a Scene Activation command was received.

[daballiemo]

but did you run using master branch of zwavejs ?
some commit in master branch are not yet released

How can I check this besides running the latest docker container? I am not a pro at this subject

[daballiemo]

@daballiemo your log does not indicate that a Scene Activation command was received.

@AlCalzone, that is exactly my problem; a double click or triple click should fire a scene. But I see nothing, not in zwave so surely not in MQTT.

[AlCalzone]

Yeah, but if the command does not reach zwave-js, the device does not send it. Or you need to add an association.

How can I check this besides running the latest docker container?

Then you're likely not running the latest master. I'm not involved with the docker releases, so you'll have to wait for @robertsLando to respond.

[daballiemo]

Hold the presses! With moving to a new controller I thought it made sense to reset the node. After that is is ofcourse a good idea to enable scenes again.....

I know see the following in the log:
22:09:40.548 SERIAL « 0x010a00040002042b011aff38 (12 bytes) 22:09:40.552 CNTRLR [Node 002] [!] [Scene Activation] sceneId: 26 [Endpoint 0] 2021-02-23 22:09:40.553 INFO ZWAVE: Node 2: value notification: 43-0-sceneId 26 22:09:40.554 CNTRLR [Node 002] [+] [Scene Activation] dimmingDuration: "default" [Endpoint 0] 2021-02-23 22:09:40.554 INFO ZWAVE: Node 2: value added: 43-0-dimmingDuration => [Duration: default] 2021-02-23 22:09:40.555 INFO ZWAVE: Node 2: value added 2-43-0-dimmingDuration => [Duration: default] 22:09:40.557 SERIAL » [ACK] (0x06) 22:09:40.562 DRIVER « [Node 002] [REQ] [ApplicationCommand] └─[SceneActivationCCSet] scene id: 26 dimming duration: [Duration: default] 22:09:40.564 CNTRLR « [Node 002] TODO: no handler for application command 22:10:02.221 SERIAL « 0x010a00040002042b0118ff3a (12 bytes) 22:10:02.222 CNTRLR [Node 002] [!] [Scene Activation] sceneId: 24 [Endpoint 0] 2021-02-23 22:10:02.223 INFO ZWAVE: Node 2: value notification: 43-0-sceneId 24 22:10:02.224 CNTRLR [Node 002] [~] [Scene Activation] dimmingDuration: "default" => " [Endpoint 0] default" 2021-02-23 22:10:02.225 INFO ZWAVE: Node 2: value updated: 43-0-dimmingDuration [Duration: default] => [Duration: default] 22:10:02.225 SERIAL » [ACK] (0x06) 22:10:02.227 DRIVER « [Node 002] [REQ] [ApplicationCommand] └─[SceneActivationCCSet] scene id: 24 dimming duration: [Duration: default] 22:10:02.229 CNTRLR « [Node 002] TODO: no handler for application command

[daballiemo]

@AlCalzone & @bdbogjoe thanks for helping out another poor soul ;-)

[AlCalzone]

💪🏻

[daballiemo]

Still wondering though were it ends up in MQTT because I only see some stuff

nodeID_2-43-0-dimmingduration {"time":1614118695044,"value":"default"}

not really any info that relates to the scenes. We'll back to the books again

[AlCalzone]

As soon as you have the updated version of zwave-js it should show up under sceneId

[daballiemo]

thx again and great support 🙏🏻