Vscode-pull-request-github: Support the new code review suggestions

Created on 23 Oct 2018  路  8Comments  路  Source: microsoft/vscode-pull-request-github


Github announced a new suggestion api that started being added to the code review tools.
Right now the extension takes these at face value as text.

For example take this comment.

In github:

image

In vscode:

image
Maybe have the suggested changes be shown as a diff? maybe even have a prompt to incorporate the changes, similarly to a merge conflict.

feature-request

Most helpful comment

Does this FR only cover displaying the suggestions made elsewhere or also being able to make suggestions from VS code? Both would be great!

All 8 comments

This would be really useful to have it when making reviews through the VS code.

With 589 and this functionality you would be pretty much be able to do the whole PR from VS code!

Does this FR only cover displaying the suggestions made elsewhere or also being able to make suggestions from VS code? Both would be great!

I found this feature very interesting.... is it gonna be put in the roadmap ?

It would be very handy if I could just open a file, make some changes in it and post them as a suggestion.

It would be really big improvements for dev productivity

Any update on this? Currently the suggestion overflow the width of the comment box without anyway to scroll
image

Yes, this feature would be very useful. Currently we can add suggestions (using ```suggestion) but they don't show up properly. For example, the suggestion to remove a line does is not displayed at all.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

erihanse picture erihanse  路  4Comments

octogonz picture octogonz  路  3Comments

jrieken picture jrieken  路  3Comments

sbatten picture sbatten  路  4Comments

kieferrm picture kieferrm  路  4Comments