Vscode-pull-request-github: Allow user to start a new comment thread on line that already has a comment

Created on 12 Sep 2018  路  2Comments  路  Source: microsoft/vscode-pull-request-github

Problem: If anyone adds a comment to a line of code, then no one else can comment on that line.
Solution: Allow multiple comments per line.

feature-request

Most helpful comment

Here's further clarification on the request:

  1. VS Code allows only allows you to respond to an existing comment, which adds it to the thread.
  2. GitHub.com allows you to add another comment to the same line, which starts a new thread. Make sure you are using the "Files Changed" tab to see this.

I also updated the title.

All 2 comments

Hey @jongio, this should already be supported. Comments are grouped into threads based on line position, as they are on GitHub. To comment on the same line you can respond to the existing thread

Here's further clarification on the request:

  1. VS Code allows only allows you to respond to an existing comment, which adds it to the thread.
  2. GitHub.com allows you to add another comment to the same line, which starts a new thread. Make sure you are using the "Files Changed" tab to see this.

I also updated the title.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

Velyks picture Velyks  路  3Comments

RamonMeffert picture RamonMeffert  路  3Comments

Tyriar picture Tyriar  路  3Comments

paulirish picture paulirish  路  3Comments

Tyriar picture Tyriar  路  4Comments