Umbraco-cms: Improve UX on the select avatar step when creating an Umbraco user from an invite

Created on 2 Oct 2018  路  7Comments  路  Source: umbraco/Umbraco-CMS

Once a person clicks the invitation link then at the end of the flow it's possible to select an avatar. Below the avatar there is a green "Get started" button and a skip link/button. It seems a bit weird since either of them will do the same thing - Namely take you to the backoffice whether you select an avatar or not :)

A screendump of the screen can be seen here

getstarted-or-skip

Perhaps the "Skip" link/button can be removed since selecting an avatar is not mandatory? Not sure what the better approach is here but it's imho a bit weird as it is now 馃槂

communitpr releas7.13.0 typfeature

Most helpful comment

To me it would still be confusing: "upload an avatar - Get Started" - sounds like I can get started with uploading an avatar.

Maybe a "Done" button instead?

Would be really nice with the 404 handling Mark mentions, but sometimes you just want to set a different picture anyway, so give people the chance: "This is how you will look right now, is that okay? You can add or change this picture by clicking the circle above". Something like that.

I've marked as "Up for grabs" so that you or someone else coming along could create a pull request for it.

All 7 comments

Spotted the same thing @BatJan, and it was slightly more confusing for me because I think Gravatar picked up my image already, so I was being asked to upload a photo but it already had one, so I didn't see the "+" icon in the circle. Maybe the text should be updated to guide users a little more: "Click on the icon above to upload an optional picture and make it easy for other users to recognise you." with just the "Get started" button? Happy to take a look at this but think we'll need some UX guidance from HQ.

Thanks for chiming in @ed-parry - Yup some text and then maybe just the "Get started" button would be nice. But I agree that some HQ input is needed for this one in order to progress - I'll be happy to give it a go as well - Whoever comes first 馃槂

But perhaps we should ask @nul800sebastiaan and @madsrasmussen about thoughts and directions for this?

Sounds good! All yours @BatJan :) I'm heading on holiday shortly so don't
want to assign things to me if there are others there for them. It's the

hacktoberfest coming out in me to go for everything 馃槄

Perhaps:

  1. Add a null check for the gravatar lookup. That is, if we append ?d=404 at the end of the url parameter we will know for sure whether it's been setup or not.

    • Error (404)? Show this screen.
    • Success? Immediately go to the backoffice.
  2. I think BatJan's recommendation of just keeping "Get Started" is best. There's no reason to make any additional actions available is there?

To me it would still be confusing: "upload an avatar - Get Started" - sounds like I can get started with uploading an avatar.

Maybe a "Done" button instead?

Would be really nice with the 404 handling Mark mentions, but sometimes you just want to set a different picture anyway, so give people the chance: "This is how you will look right now, is that okay? You can add or change this picture by clicking the circle above". Something like that.

I've marked as "Up for grabs" so that you or someone else coming along could create a pull request for it.

Yup simply a "Done" button would actually be the nicest option I think.

Then maybe the avatar thingy can use the gravatar, if possible or use one of those random images like when new users sign up on Our and then the "Upload Photo" could be changed to "Change avatar?" instead?

PR in #3812

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings