Tmpe: Timed traffic lights - warn if segments to short

Created on 3 May 2019  路  7Comments  路  Source: CitiesSkylinesMods/TMPE

When there are very short road segments near timed traffic lights, it seems to break the traffic lights.

It would be good if we could warn the user about problematic segments.

I do not know what the segment length threshold should be, but it's possible to reproduce the error in the save supplied in #297

I suspect the segment length issue would also impact things like junction restrictions, but have not confirmed this.

TRAFFIC LIGHTS enhancement low priority

Most helpful comment

There is a possible fix mentioned in #666 - reduce speed on the short segments.

All 7 comments

Tagging #8

Maybe not entirely only warn, but if there's any way we could add support for shorter segments would probably be a much more superior fix than just warning them. This could allow things like cool interchanges with slip-on and slip-off lanes (like the single-point urban interchange) to work. I will try and remember to provide images later.

Agreed, if we could find what's causing the issue and fix it that would be best.

If not, we should find a way to warn users about the issue.

Images of practical use of short segments will be useful to show why a fix is preferable.

Thank you for the suggestion! For the roads in my country, slip roads are littered at almost every traffic junction:

A typical traffic junction with slip roads for the expressway:
https://goo.gl/maps/C4X2wgkMoGHsxFDq5

A typical traffic junction with slips roads:
https://goo.gl/maps/YvbEMjugwLs4yotk8

If you noticed, this is the exact same junction that I was trying to mimic but failed to do so due to this bug/error where segments are too close to each other.

It would be even better, if there is a possibility to fix the broken behaviour, This error is very frustrating and even happening on segments long enough for like two trucks with trailers.

There is a possible fix mentioned in #666 - reduce speed on the short segments.

Yeah, found that too, can confirm that lowering the speed limit is working.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

kianzarrin picture kianzarrin  路  39Comments

FireController1847 picture FireController1847  路  28Comments

aubergine10 picture aubergine10  路  41Comments

scottmcm picture scottmcm  路  29Comments

darthroe picture darthroe  路  249Comments