Screentogif: [Feature request] Color limiter

Created on 23 Apr 2018  路  2Comments  路  Source: NickeManarin/ScreenToGif

Disclaimer: There might be a way to do this properly but at least with the tools I used, lowering colors didn't seem to help, probably because it creates additional changes between frames.

I got this idea while responding to #299.


Background: I use ScreenToGif to help demonstrate short processes and for writing up bug reports, frequently I don't need precise detail to explain what I'm trying to do. Currently ScreenToGif saves to the 256 color standard. With fewer colors, I think you might see file sizes decrease.

I tried to put together a process to demonstrate how taking images recorded in ScreenToGif and using other tools with converters that remove colors would result in lower file sizes. Strangely, I tried the following workaround and -- for reasons I can't explain, none if to worked. Fewer colors (black and white, 64 color, 8 color even) strangely resulted in LARGER files sizes. I really can't explain why as I've done this previously with other GIF animation tools with very different results.

Workaround:

  1. Record something and save as project (such as _Recording.STG_)
  2. Unzip the .STG file using a program like 7zip to get access to the individual images
  3. Run with a program like XnConvert and add all the files
  4. Click Add Action - Reduce Colors (make sure to disable dithering)

2018-04-22 19_50_24-xnconvert

  1. Select an output folder and convert
  2. Re-import back into the program (go to the output folder and select all)
  3. Save to GIF or other format

Output

256 colors:
test88767-high

Black and White:
test88767-bw

Note that converting to APNG format did nothing. The files with more colors were still somehow smaller. Maybe it's the converter I was using.

Most helpful comment

With the encoder v2.0 you can reduce the number of colors.

All 2 comments

With the encoder v2.0 you can reduce the number of colors.

Wow, it was that easy? Jeeze.

image

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

AdKiller picture AdKiller  路  5Comments

Kristinita picture Kristinita  路  4Comments

hanzhangyu picture hanzhangyu  路  3Comments

ghost picture ghost  路  4Comments

daniloalonso picture daniloalonso  路  5Comments