Qksms: Photo cropping and aspect ratio

Created on 23 Jun 2018  路  3Comments  路  Source: moezbhatti/qksms

When displaying an MMS conversation with photos, QKSMS seems to crop the photos to a roughly square shape. This is not good, because important parts of the photo may be hidden by the cropping. Photos should be displayed in the original aspect ratio without any cropping.

The current behavior could be retained as an option if desired, but I don't think it should be the default behavior.

enhancement

Most helpful comment

Personally I'd be willing to sacrifice a little scrolling smoothness to allow photos to show in original aspect ratio.

A few ideas that might help minimize the UI jumping:

  • Use a fixed vertical image height
  • Cache the image dimensions in the database

All 3 comments

The current implementation isn't meant to be a permanent solution. If I can figure out how to maintain the aspect ratio without any issues, I'd love to do so

The problem is that the app needs to load the photo info in order to determine the aspect ratio, which can take a few frames. This means that it will only be determined after it's already being displayed, and because you're scrolling in a list, it causes the UI to jump around

Personally I'd be willing to sacrifice a little scrolling smoothness to allow photos to show in original aspect ratio.

A few ideas that might help minimize the UI jumping:

  • Use a fixed vertical image height
  • Cache the image dimensions in the database

just wanted to spin out this bug from #1220 , thanks @spocko ;)
(can you just edit / refine the title to not only address "cropping" but "aspect")

here are some screenshots
Google Messages:

QKSMS

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

nosoop picture nosoop  路  4Comments

ZenithRogue picture ZenithRogue  路  5Comments

SeriousTube picture SeriousTube  路  3Comments

xavihernandez picture xavihernandez  路  4Comments

moezbhatti picture moezbhatti  路  3Comments