Picongpu: Docs suggestion: extend Basics with info on stdout and output directory?

Created on 12 Feb 2020  路  3Comments  路  Source: ComputationalRadiationPhysics/picongpu

While thinking about adding readthedocs covering of #3163, I found myself unsure where to better add it. After going through the docs for a little, got an idea that maybe the basics section should also cover what output (both stdout and the output directory) will a user get after running PIConGPU. Perhaps just after this subsection. If put there, could use the LWFA example that was built and run just before.

I could provide a PR for this, just wanted to discuss beforehand.

documentation

Most helpful comment

I would suggest a very brief mention at the end of 3. Run Simulation (see now the simOutput/ dir and the progress in simOutput/output).

Then add a new page between .param Files and Plugins that explains general output structure (maybe name it Output). We guarantee in job script templates: there will be an simOutput/output file. We do not guarantee the name of the ./stdout|error file (besides trying to prefix it as such, but batch systems might add suffixes).

All 3 comments

@ComputationalRadiationPhysics/picongpu-maintainers what are your opinions on this?

It definitely does not hurt but should be kept very brief.
Especially the stdout can, on the one hand, tell you useful things but should not be the main source of information and the estimates in there should not be trusted blindly.
They come with assumptions that are not documented, yet, and therefore it is good to document them.
However, our main validity checks should always come from checking the real data - so it's important not to dwell to extensively on the stdout.

I would suggest a very brief mention at the end of 3. Run Simulation (see now the simOutput/ dir and the progress in simOutput/output).

Then add a new page between .param Files and Plugins that explains general output structure (maybe name it Output). We guarantee in job script templates: there will be an simOutput/output file. We do not guarantee the name of the ./stdout|error file (besides trying to prefix it as such, but batch systems might add suffixes).

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

berceanu picture berceanu  路  4Comments

ax3l picture ax3l  路  3Comments

hightower8083 picture hightower8083  路  4Comments

steindev picture steindev  路  4Comments

saipavankalyan picture saipavankalyan  路  3Comments