Osu: Quick retry should have an option to use hold-to-confirm even when it's set to 0ms

Created on 4 Oct 2019  路  2Comments  路  Source: ppy/osu

Quick retry depending on what key you have it set to might be the only button you can accidentally hit during gameplay and is the only button where such accidental hit loses you the entire run. As such it should have an option to use separate hold-to-confirm value.

UX

Most helpful comment

The entire point of adding 0ms delay was to address the concerns of users who specifically did not want the hold-to-confirm behaviour (see #5402). In my opinion if the hold-to-confirm delay was set to 0ms, then the user explicitly agrees that it will be such, potentially to their detriment.

It is not wise to keep escalating the number of possible settings endlessly. I don't think anyone wants to end up with and/or maintain a baroque selection of multiplying settings with non-trivial interdependencies.

All 2 comments

The entire point of adding 0ms delay was to address the concerns of users who specifically did not want the hold-to-confirm behaviour (see #5402). In my opinion if the hold-to-confirm delay was set to 0ms, then the user explicitly agrees that it will be such, potentially to their detriment.

It is not wise to keep escalating the number of possible settings endlessly. I don't think anyone wants to end up with and/or maintain a baroque selection of multiplying settings with non-trivial interdependencies.

I wouldn't call just having another slider explicitly for hold-to-retry a non-trivial interdependence.

I'm one of those users who don't want hold-to-confirm behaviour. Except for hold-to-retry.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

lenzfilipski picture lenzfilipski  路  3Comments

skhrenov picture skhrenov  路  3Comments

LevKatenin picture LevKatenin  路  3Comments

smileyhead picture smileyhead  路  3Comments

smileyhead picture smileyhead  路  3Comments