Osu-web: Map creators should be able to thumbs-down suggestions

Created on 5 Jan 2018  路  2Comments  路  Source: ppy/osu-web

I often see modders wall modding a tonne of suggestions with really unhelpful ideas, and asking their friend to mass upvote them for kudosu, regardless of whether or not the mapper agreed with it. The mapper needs to be able to downvote discussions they did not find helpful. If there are suggestions that should be helpful but the mapper disagrees, other users can still outvote the mapper if it's deemed helpful by the community.
Thumbs-down would also really help other users know if a mapper accepted or rejected a suggestion, and would be a really helpful side-effect.

(imo) An alternate solution would be that the creator is the only person who can give kudosu, but others can still react with thumbs, which eliminates the problem.

It's also quite difficult to keep up with kudosu abuse. There are so many people doing it and so few members that are capable of revoking it. Wasn't an issue on the old forum since it was clear who was responsible for abusing kudosu, and can be held accountable.

beatmap-discussions proposal

Most helpful comment

It would be nice to show the mapper's response next to the vote options when the mapper does vote [mapper approves] [mapper dislikes] or something.

All 2 comments

It would be nice to show the mapper's response next to the vote options when the mapper does vote [mapper approves] [mapper dislikes] or something.

Yeah, i think there could be some indication of whether the mapper actually took the modder's suggestion, or did not. Similar to how in modv1 people usually color coded what was fixed and what was rejected.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

shortthu picture shortthu  路  5Comments

Cynplytholowazy picture Cynplytholowazy  路  4Comments

venix12 picture venix12  路  3Comments

downpour-osu picture downpour-osu  路  4Comments

Xinnoh picture Xinnoh  路  5Comments