Newpipe: Android 11: notification can't be restored after being swiped away

Created on 16 Oct 2020  路  5Comments  路  Source: TeamNewPipe/NewPipe

Checklist

Steps to reproduce the bug

  1. Android 11
  2. Add videos to the background queue.
  3. Open the notification shade.
  4. Swipe away NewPipe notification (playback continues).
    4a. Fully expand quick settings area to show NewPipe player controls.
    4b. Fully expand quick settings area and open the background queue in NewPipe.
  5. Interact with the player - play/pause, change tracks.

Actual behaviour

NewPipe notification doesn't reappear. It will appear again only after you clear the queue and start playback again.

Expected behavior

NewPipe notification should reappear as soon as you interact with the player controls (either from the quick settings area or within the app).
This behavior can be seen with the Google Play Music app.

Device info

  • Android version/Custom ROM version: Android 11
  • Device model: Pixel 3a
bug notification

Most helpful comment

When would you expect the notification to appear again?

=>

NewPipe notification should reappear as soon as you interact with the player controls (either from the quick settings area or within the app). This behavior can be seen with the Google Play Music app.


if you swiped it away on purpose it should stay hidden until the player is restarted, shouldn't it?

The player is not stopped, it keeps playing. So now I have to interrupt playback before I can make the notification appear again.

Otherwise why would you have swiped it away?

On accident, while clearing other notifications, obviously.

I really can't understand what the purpose of this new Android 11 feature is

Neither can I, but it's already here, and I doubt that we can convince Google to change it.

All 5 comments

@Stypox This needs both a working Android 11 emulator and the 'Save queue to disk' feature as a prerequisite, right?

Save queue to disk

Why would that be needed? The queue doesn't get erased when notification is swiped away, and playback continues just fine. I still can access the queue, just not from the notification.

Oh. Okay.

When would you expect the notification to appear again? I mean, if you swiped it away on purpose it should stay hidden until the player is restarted, shouldn't it? Otherwise why would you have swiped it away? I really can't understand what the purpose of this new Android 11 feature is, and until I can't get a working emulator I can't test anything.

When would you expect the notification to appear again?

=>

NewPipe notification should reappear as soon as you interact with the player controls (either from the quick settings area or within the app). This behavior can be seen with the Google Play Music app.


if you swiped it away on purpose it should stay hidden until the player is restarted, shouldn't it?

The player is not stopped, it keeps playing. So now I have to interrupt playback before I can make the notification appear again.

Otherwise why would you have swiped it away?

On accident, while clearing other notifications, obviously.

I really can't understand what the purpose of this new Android 11 feature is

Neither can I, but it's already here, and I doubt that we can convince Google to change it.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings