Magisk blocks Andrax! Need to delete?

[vertolazer]

I am very upset that Magisk is blocking Andrax !! If in the near future this does not change, I will have to put another root!

[unixandria-xda]

I am very upset that Magisk is blocking Andrax !! If in the near future this does not change, I will have to put another root!

First of all it's actually the opposite way around. Andrax blocks magisk, which also means any other root method will have the same result if it doesn't flat out brick your device.

Also: #1152

[unixandria-xda]

Highly recommend closing as it's already known there's several working methods to detect magisk and @topjohnwu is working on what he can

[NH-Killer]

They are talking about ANDRAX: https://andrax.thecrackertechnology.com damn,,,

I am very upset that Magisk is blocking Andrax !! If in the near future this does not change, I will have to put another root!

First of all it's actually the opposite way around. Andrax blocks magisk, which also means any other root method will have the same result if it doesn't flat out brick your device.

Also: #1152

[NH-Killer]

Chroot by magisk does not work on some devices with android 9 and 10 syscall never starts.

Close issue without responding clearly states that they know what is happening and it is purposeful

[Didgeridoohan]

Chroot by magisk does not work on some devices with android 9 and 10 syscall never starts.

Close issue without responding clearly states that they know what is happening and it is purposeful

Wow... Paranoid much? Your issue was closed because it didn't contain any kind of useful information that would be expected in a bug report.

[NH-Killer]

Chroot by magisk does not work on some devices with android 9 and 10 syscall never starts.
Close issue without responding clearly states that they know what is happening and it is purposeful

Wow... Paranoid much? Your issue was closed because it didn't contain any kind of useful information that would be expected in a bug report.

Don't exist any information, simple like that chroot is blocked and never start... is impossible strace too... no error...

[NH-Killer]

And useful information is not to harm one system to favor another!

[Didgeridoohan]

And useful information is not to harm one system to favor another!

Ok, my curiosity is getting the better of my and I'll bite. What kind of blocking and harm is it that you guys think that Magisk is doing?

[NH-Killer]

And useful information is not to harm one system to favor another!

Ok, my curiosity is getting the better of my and I'll bite. What kind of blocking and harm is it that you guys think that Magisk is doing?

Can you tell me? Closing all threads related with ANDRAX...

Let me try explain...

I'm the dev of ANDRAX, ANDRAX need chroot to start our container...

If we try run chroot in a root shell the container never start only keep in a type of "loading" stat, we cant strace because strace keep in this "loading" type.

This only occour in some devices with Android 9 and 10, my users tried canary builds too

[Didgeridoohan]

There's no conspiracy (as you seem to think)...

The issue are closed because all they say is "something doesn't work, fix" without anything to go on.

If there's a bug in Magisk, find it and provide the proper information for John to work with. He's not gonna go jump through hoops for you...

[unixandria-xda]

TBH I thought it was another magiskhide not works plz fix issue lol

[NH-Killer]

There's no conspiracy (as you seem to think)...

The issue are closed because all they say is "something doesn't work, fix" without anything to go on.

If there's a bug in Magisk, find it and provide the proper information for John to work with. He's not gonna go jump through hoops for you...

Maybe will take a while, i downloaded the source code... don't worry more about it, when i find the problem i'll provide a fix but source closed to my users if you don't want help, i not will help too...

[Didgeridoohan]

Wow...

I'm curious though: where did you read that nobody here wants help?

[osm0sis]

That also would violate GPL, so.. :roll_eyes:

[NH-Killer]

That also would violate GPL, so.. roll_eyes

antitrust

[osm0sis]

Cool story. Locking this now due to your behavior. When you can provide a clear issue report at a reasonable level of discourse feel free to open a new issue.