Fenix: Remove background of "legacy" icons

Created on 22 Aug 2020  ·  9Comments  ·  Source: mozilla-mobile/fenix

What is the user problem or growth opportunity you want to see solved?

Just fits in better.

How do you know that this problem exists today? Why is this important?

It's not a big problem but it doesn't really fit in.

Who will benefit from it?

Users on Android 7 and below, and those on Android 8 and above with launchers that use legacy icons.

UX-feedback 🐞 bug

Most helpful comment

The now discontinued org.mozilla.fennec_aurora package had the proper non-adaptive Nightly icon for example, whereas org.mozilla.fenix suffers from the described issue.

All 9 comments

What do you mean by "legacy icon"? A screenshot would help!

Android 8 introduced adaptive icons. Google refers to shapeless icons as legacy icons. Here's a comparison of Firefox (Fennec) vs Firefox Beta (Fenix)
117919112_386908462305987_3120042354671164668_n

Thanks!

The now discontinued org.mozilla.fennec_aurora package had the proper non-adaptive Nightly icon for example, whereas org.mozilla.fenix suffers from the described issue.

@NotWoods do you know anything about these legacy icons and if we have the right assets?

We can probably just resize the assets from mozilla.design, but maybe @shorlander has appropriately sized and padded transparent icons for Android already?

Adding screenshots.

Proper older icon (Firefox 68.11.0): https://i.imgur.com/GyrXUCg.jpg

Current "Fenix" messed-up icon:
https://i.imgur.com/ZpWIP2S.jpg

Regards.

Looks like this also affects the release channel. I've kept my release install on fennec so I didn't know.

No one?

Please try to use Firefox on Android 5.1.1, so you can see what's we're talking about.

The icon size is currently ugly, very small and no transparency.

Icon is part of the branding, so this is not trivial matter.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings