Element-android: Option to disable emoji keyboard

Created on 20 Dec 2020  路  4Comments  路  Source: vector-im/element-android

The button to open Element's new emoji keyboard takes a lot of space from an already small input field. My keyboard has a perfectly good built-in emoji input option that doesn't take space from the input field, so I'd like to hide the one in Element.

An alternative would be to make the input field buttons more compact and reduce horizontal padding in the input field. Telegram at least seems to do it much better.

emoji suggestion

Most helpful comment

We will add a setting "Show Emoji keyboard", set to true by default, in Settings/Preferences/Message Editor section.

All 4 comments

I'm in no position to decide what's good or bad for element-android, but I cast my vote that #2514 as a whole should be reverted. It goes against any rationale for good software design.

@ManDay each has it's own arguments ... I think it should at leas be a Option instead of removing it completely, since there is a demand for that ...

Are there really that many keyboard apps that don't ship with Emojis? I always use the built-in one like @tulir. It's in my muscle memory and I don't have to remember for each messenger app where the emoji button is located.
I also have to agree with @ManDay that an app shouldn't deal with another dependency that needs to be updated every time Unicode adds new Emojis/Glyphs for example.
Also, the Emoji library adds around 2.4 MB in APK size according to here.
If we leave the emoji picker in, should it per default be disabled?

We will add a setting "Show Emoji keyboard", set to true by default, in Settings/Preferences/Message Editor section.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

Yajo picture Yajo  路  3Comments

jwsp1 picture jwsp1  路  3Comments

steef435 picture steef435  路  3Comments

David-Else picture David-Else  路  3Comments

Bubu picture Bubu  路  3Comments