[x] If you are proposing a new feature, please do so in CWA-Wishlist
I have carefully read https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-backlog/issues/23
The app shows low risk exposures and suggests the same behavior as in the case of no low risk exposures.
Hide low risk exposures per default as these can unnerve insecure people to a degree that leads them to uninstall the app. But add an option to turn it on.
I live with a woman in her 60s who received a low risk exposure notification. She was extremely upset by this and checked the app every day since then, hoping that the notification had vanished.
She consulted with me, both of her sons and several friends about this and also read up on it herself.
After all this she was still insecure. She did not understand why a low risk notification is shown when no precautions need to be taken.
Saying that its purpose is transparency, so that people can decide for themselves if they want to be extra careful, did not help. _She simply didn’t know how she should decide to be extra careful or not._
When she first brought up the idea of uninstalling the app because it made her anxious, I was able to talk her out of it. But several days later the notification was still there, creeping her out. She made the final decision to uninstall.
Her problem is clearly not a lack of information on the status, rather too much information combined with too much own responsibility and too little confidence on the topic.
Although transparency is a good thing if I can make informed decisions based on it, it is not useful in and of itself. Since time, duration and location of the exposure are not shared due to data protection, _there is no information to base a decision on_. Hence, the transparency serves no purpose.
If there _are_ reasonable decisions one could make based on the notification alone, such as _Refrain from meeting old people_ or _Don’t go to work_, they’d be the same for all low risk exposed people and could therefore be added to the behavior guidlines in the app.
Apparently this isn’t the case, so I don’t see the purpose of displaying the exposure at all.
Keeping insecure people from uninstalling the app while satisfying the transparency wishes of other people at the same time.
Opened in correct repo: https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-wishlist/issues/181
Most helpful comment
Opened in correct repo: https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-wishlist/issues/181