Contao: All routes are registered twice?
Affected version(s)
Contao 4.10
Description
tl_page.12 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/your-data-has-been-saved{!parameters}.html
tl_page.64 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/user{!parameters}.html
tl_page.31 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/top-menu-folder{!parameters}.html
tl_page.32 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/sitemap{!parameters}.html
tl_page.14 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/search{!parameters}.html
tl_page.2 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/index{!parameters}.html
tl_page.60 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/faq{!parameters}.html
tl_page.59 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/events{!parameters}.html
tl_page.70 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/event-detail{!parameters}.html
tl_page.51 ANY https managed-edition.wip /en/content-elements/text-elements{!parameters}.html
tl_page.12.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /your-data-has-been-saved{!parameters}.html
tl_page.64.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /user{!parameters}.html
tl_page.31.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /top-menu-folder{!parameters}.html
tl_page.32.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /sitemap{!parameters}.html
tl_page.14.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /search{!parameters}.html
tl_page.2.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /index{!parameters}.html
tl_page.60.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /faq{!parameters}.html
tl_page.59.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /events{!parameters}.html
tl_page.70.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /event-detail{!parameters}.html
tl_page.51.locale ANY https managed-edition.wip /content-elements/text-elements{!parameters}.html
IIRC, there is a redirect route "no locale → locale" for every single page now, which was not the case in Contao 4.9 (routes look like /{_locale}/content-elements/text-elements{parameters}.html there). IMHO, we only need the "no locale → locale" redirect for the empty domain. Otherwise we will end up with a large number of routes (number of pages * number of languages).
leofeyer
>All comments
Yes, every page can have multiple routes, depending on your configuration. If you have a url prefix, every route exists again with a redirect if the user does not enter the language. Thats how www.contao.org/partners.html will/might redirect you to www.contao.org/de/partners.html. Every root/index page has a route with and without url prefix and/or alias etc.
However, please be aware that these routes do not really exists at the same time in a normal flow. You are looking at the debug information, only in debug mode all routes are generated (to - hahah - let you debug and see them). In a regular flow, only routes for pages matching the request path are generated. Only if none of that match the _404 router_ will try to generate a locale redirect, or lastly resort to generating the 404 error page route.
aschempp
on 30 Jul 2020
Related issues
Xirdion
·
3Comments
zonky2
·
3Comments
fritzmg
·
3Comments
fritzmg
·
3Comments
adojck
·
3Comments
Most helpful comment
Yes, every page can have multiple routes, depending on your configuration. If you have a url prefix, every route exists again with a redirect if the user does not enter the language. Thats how
www.contao.org/partners.htmlwill/might redirect you towww.contao.org/de/partners.html. Every root/index page has a route with and without url prefix and/or alias etc.However, please be aware that these routes do not really exists at the same time in a normal flow. You are looking at the debug information, only in debug mode all routes are generated (to - hahah - let you debug and see them). In a regular flow, only routes for pages matching the request path are generated. Only if none of that match the _404 router_ will try to generate a locale redirect, or lastly resort to generating the 404 error page route.