Client: reddit proof bug

[edwynchan]

I followed the instructions and posted it twice but still does not verify

https://www.reddit.com/r/KeybaseProofs/comments/8gh65y/my_keybase_proof_redditedwyn_keybaseedwyn/

https://www.reddit.com/r/KeybaseProofs/comments/8gh3g2/my_keybase_proof_redditedwyn_keybaseedwyn_fhr54nw/

[5h4d0ww0lf]

Maybe this is how right proof look https://www.reddit.com/r/KeybaseProofs/comments/80l965/my_keybase_proof_reddit5h4d0ww0lf/

[5h4d0ww0lf]

You totally miss the whole body of message

[edwynchan]

@5h4d0ww0lf there seems to be some problem with the pre-filled form on Mac. I tried both on safari and on chrome. the message of the pre-filled form does not show when I submit

[williamdes]

I found a way to fix this:

1. Open pre filled form
2. Switch to markdown mode
3. Replace all + by a space (do not do this after -----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE----- and before -----END PGP MESSAGE----- )

PS: be sure to leave the new line after the signature

Preview : http://markdownlivepreview.com/

Before

###+Keybase+proof

I+am:

++*+[wdesportes](https://www.reddit.com/user/wdesportes)+on+reddit.
++*+[williamdes](https://keybase.io/williamdes)+on+keybase.

Proof:

++++-----BEGIN+PGP+MESSAGE-----
++++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++++=TX/W
++++-----END+PGP+MESSAGE-----

After

### Keybase proof

I am:

  * [wdesportes](https://www.reddit.com/user/wdesportes) on reddit.
  * [williamdes](https://keybase.io/williamdes) on keybase.

Proof:

    -----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----

    owGtk3tMFFcUxkFFkdYHWl9YX6MlYBBm5s7cubOG+oBSTYVWqlUhdb0z914ZFnaX
    2QWhSOsDtTQiq2kxVo2KEny0ilhfa2LVWm3SSqOioJL4qKJIlNj3y6Z3qSaN6Z+d
    SWYyJ+d85zu/OTfQp3tYVHhga+fwZTN3VoR/3W6EZXXGBEsFw0NKBEep4KJdL5pH
    qM/vdFlEcAiiJEqGYhoIIkwNBjSVUgqBIgMNiCIyJSoiA4iYMBVKVBJ1UxMNiUiA
    AVmjOlBUqIhYSBCY5V5Iba9tuf1c1lSILjHCTMqgoWBgQhUwoiFdxCJlkoFkVcII
    6bwwx+MLVXBzBvbRRMvDY/zD2WXvP/L/Z9+FXXJAMyBSDFnFRKKQPwyGDJXfRIOQ
    SKG+hT5qu3E+5dmLrLw8C+dzjEJZgpBPbVceddoejz+E1/RboSRJlXlnHagqHxH7
    cpz51I95LYUUMVXUGJE1EelAQ6bMoIyJjqmmyITIUCIiIxBqDEkKwTrkvhSFyRLQ
    VUPkTny0wO0RHLKiywBI3IFNizwuGmrusxZycD7BkS0oxgkflJmJKQcCCKYK0Ilo
    cGVND/0UCFUMETGxRhHWINMNjAwGCSZYlU3F0KHIhLfLQu3sIsvskn8yv00JsfzP
    MOE0vB7b/w8Tf4m3K0gN55Nyp2G5Cd8RXlVEbZ/lcXNGPPMZXJqSINBir2VTpxXK
    UDWIRH4lCF4+JZeUgKhzDrLBVwzJCIpQNgBFqo4UHamEMEkFEhYZwrKiEU0lKt8T
    hWINAR0xjf6bH/eJF3JNTs2N/YU2FcqiKrqBHmHhUWEjBo/pcfrKqOuNP3+2/cyb
    j4ufnquIbqFDFRbVu//TSHBbv8cxca9kzJkw4PKOYPr39R0pcecLXm5vsX/KSo3/
    MqMt59jGKU32gqZzvdbdSP5g3LH78fvDevabUXo2q2lWzCfhKXuVTX+1vhsxNKXw
    04721rT+gwLnLyWOrCm/MKs0OLlg5OB39rBv33eMaT28eVcA3Zn5sHls/JStk2F2
    iuPuwWk3b+XW/UZXD9m1KWlC9Kp7L1x0RH1+/cyDxIEPWtqmVtXHZu5OLBw6N/rV
    2JXrr/0OF2/ZuaXNGp2+tOfSBleSPE7ZNLFlXnpxzqi+845vWNy4Kv3RuJuVM9mt
    VDmt/qDYEDF/9msn36qacOeHfNg4ce/y6ZN01+2vTg2qPTWt70NnUtlL/b2d9y9l
    Z99+Pju5d1Fexi/NubNr5qTciM9NjVmyoO7HuXb0kjeuDWiaPmL42itXpXX1U/dd
    T9pb254ZPrbh6L4jwUHbMqsrh0VWLQquQR+NPnA28HHH1cjq6rqS1Ivm9g+bx7s2
    V1dUVld3Bu3KS0LyozjS8EXVECG5IrAoxp0enrn2j5PvJZQs7uOourdh7q2adbXF
    a34dVd94YOLq/UcHnI6tKJ+x1XuhaEn55ObnBv753ZDOSZPa7j/Wep4bvn53S5kw
    LDLtdTF6xZ66I8frHW3f9DmUk9FrxKGIWnoiNi4zNbds/LLIgStblR2HCzYqQiDg
    OpB12REJll9LO5i8u2Y1OtcO8rvXejvuXnxxfuPf
    =TX/W
    -----END PGP MESSAGE-----

[edwynchan]

@williamdes got it to work but I had to also replace the + with spaces also between -----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE----- and -----END PGP MESSAGE-----

[williamdes]

This is a bug or not finally ?
It was working perfectly when I created that one 20 days ago

[williamdes]

Did not verify when had no content, related to https://github.com/keybase/proofs/pull/99.
Should work soon...

[maxtaco]

Cc @mlsteele

On Sun, May 6, 2018 at 4:48 PM William Desportes [e-mail]
wrote:

Related to keybase/proofs#99 https://github.com/keybase/proofs/pull/99

—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
https://github.com/keybase/client/issues/11630#issuecomment-386912312,
or mute the thread
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AA05_yGWqqYZWSXIhEQTg_hjkr6OgMXlks5tv2GzgaJpZM4TvsVg
.

[mlsteele]

This should be fixed in the next client release coming up real soon.

@williamdes FYI I changed my mind about https://github.com/keybase/proofs/pull/99 with https://github.com/keybase/proofs/pull/100. Instead opting to use old.reddit.com and change the escaping rules on the client.

[williamdes]

Thank you @mlsteele for taking the time to explain :)