Amp-wp: Discovery - define which page elements should be zoomed, and which should not

[MackenzieHartung]

As a user I want to be able to zoom out/in elements on the editor page. Not all elements should be capable of zoom in/out.

AC1: Discovery - define which page elements should be zoomed, and which should not (e.g. Navigation, block borders)

[swissspidy]

So there is this interesting WIP pull request on the Gutenberg repository which also introduces that notion of zooming.

[miina]

Looks like the WIP PR got closed, also, it looks like it's purpose was more similar to the Instagram-like focus than actual Zooming -- it seemed to separate the block for editing without distractions.

To clarify:
Is the goal of this discovery to figure out

• a) How to keep some of the elements the same size even while the user is zooming (using the default zoom)? For example so that only the (selected) Page would zoom when the user is zooming and the other elements, such as the block navigation etc. would remain the same?
• b) Add a functionality which would programmatically zoom specific elements? E.g. there would be buttons which would zoom the Page in-out while everything else would stay the same.

Did you understand something like this or something different over the call today? Would appreciate your thoughts. cc @kienstra @swissspidy

[kienstra]

Hi @miina,
Looking over my notes from the call, your 2 points above look right.

a) Yes, I think it was mentioned that the elements that appear on the front-end should be able to zoom, like the Page. While any editor-specific elements, like the toolbar, shouldn't be able to.

b) I'm not sure if there was discussion about 'programmatically zooming' in the call, though that's not to say it doesn't apply. I'm not sure about the specifics about how it would happen.

[swissspidy]

How to keep some of the elements the same size even while the user is zooming (using the default zoom)?

If with "default zoom" you mean zooming in the browser using Ctrl++ / Ctrl+-, then I don't think it's technically possible to restrict this to a certain area. Nor would that be advisable to implement.

Add a functionality which would programmatically zoom specific elements? E.g. there would be buttons which would zoom the Page in-out while everything else would stay the same.

Yes, that was my understanding. Click on zoom button -> page is displayed bigger, which makes it easier to edit -> block toolbar etc. stay small.

[miina]

Nor would that be advisable to implement.

Yep, 100% agreed with that.

Yes, that was my understanding. Click on zoom button -> page is displayed bigger, which makes it easier to edit -> block toolbar etc. stay small.

Looks like one option for doing that could be using scaling via transform, basically what we're doing when reordering pages and previewing templates. Not sure how accurate it would look like though, we've had issues with positioning the element before to match the view, pure scaling doesn't seem to work.

Found an example (see under "Zooming inside a container") searching which uses transform for that.

[miina]

Is the main goal of this feature to be able to have better editing experience by zooming into the currently active page? Or was there any other goal behind it?

One option could be adding just one zooming point, e.g. zoom in for scaling X% and zoom back out.

Another thing to consider is that if we're zooming just the one active page then this means that the room that we have for this page would need to stay the same (since everything else around it is staying the same), so we should handle the zoom within a container.

An alternative could be having a "zoom mode" (a bit more similar idea to the upstream PR that got closed) which would:

• Turn on the Fullscreen mode.
• Display the active page X% larger.
• Adjust the styling so that the Page would have enough room for being X% larger while still keeping the relevant settings etc. visible. (Since Fullscreen would hide the menus, we'd have more room)

Not sure. Thoughts?

[swissspidy]

My understanding was that this would allow for a better editing experience because zooming in on the current page would hide the other elements like the menus, etc. (since you want to focus on editing that page). So more like the second version you describe.

[cathibosco]

Checking my understanding: So this is similar editing a post using elements of classic editor in "Distraction Free Mode" without removing the document and block editor and tools.

https://canddstudios.d.pr/Gqtk21

[miina]

Correct, and with displaying the Page larger as normal as well ("zoomed").

We'll discuss/confirm this in a few hours today.