Zerotierone: Moon Issue between versions

[thenightfighter]

Hey,
I saw some trouble between 1.2.8 and 1.2.10 and the moon feature.
I started a moon with version 1.2.8 and saw an issue which said I need to upgrade to 1.2.10. I updated to the latest version and added some more moons to the moon.json but after that none of the moons are shown up on the zerotier-cli listpeers as moons... Each moon was with the role "LEAF" in my list. I tested arroud and created a new orbit with version 1.2.8 and updated to 1.2.10. This works but if I try to change and resign my moon.json it will break the whole thing.

[glimberg]

Could you please list the specific steps to reproduce this issue?

[thenightfighter]

Sure :)

zerotier-idtool initmoon >>moon.json

With version 1.2.8:
add some lines to moon.json

zerotier-idtool genmoon moon.json

mv 000000deadbeef00.moon moons.d/000000deadbeef00.moon

add client to this orbit

Update to version 1.2.10 so that the moon will work and shown up at zerotier-cli listpeers

Make some changes to your moon.json

zerotier-idtool genmoon moon.json

mv 000000deadbeef00.moon moons.d/000000deadbeef00.moon

systemctl restart zerotier-one.service

And from now if you restart a clients zerotier you will see only a "LEAF" instead of "MOON".

[adamierymenko]

I believe this is fixed. We're going to push 1.2.12 soon. After we do that please let us know if this is still a problem. Try the dev branch if you want to test beforehand.

[leviacn]

I updated to1.2.12,but see only "leaf" instead of "moon" still

[ppcharlier]

Hello,

I'm having the same issue, with the exception that my laptop is displaying "MOON" correctly, but when I try to do the same on a client RPi it doesn't work. I don't know if it was someone else case but the reason I run different versions of ZT is simply because of the versions availability for different OS'es. But the thing is I would have thought the newer version would be compatible with files generated by older version, not the other way around... and it is working for the mac client (even though I had to manually add the files + use the orbit command after), but I can't get the linux client to recognise the moons. Tried with and without leading zeros for the network, no change

To explain my setup a little :
Moons:
Root 1: Synology DSM 6.2 ZT 1.2.8r0 _(on which I generated the .moon config file)_
Root 2: RaspberryPi 3B+ Raspian Linux 4.14.79-v7+ ZT 1.2.12

Clients:
Client 1: macOS 10.14.1 ZT 1.2.12
Client 2: RaspberryPi 3B+ Raspian Linux 4.14.79-v7+ ZT 1.2.12

Edit: I also tried generating the .moon file on the root 2 (Raspberry with ZT 1.2.12) with same issue, mac client OK but RPi client only sees LEAF where it should be MOON

Edit 2: I picked a VPS now to try with a public static IP, clean machine. Debian Jessie, ZT version 1.2.12 and trying to make it a moon for the 2 clients just make the same result : mac client seen it as a MOON, the raspberry as a LEAF. I'll have a try on windows perhaps.
_Thing I noticed, when I compare the too answers to the listpeers command is that the moon is listed with /9993 port on the mac, but with a random /27811 port on the RPi_

[hhhnb]

Hello,

I'm having the same issue, with the exception that my laptop is displaying "MOON" correctly, but when I try to do the same on a client RPi it doesn't work. I don't know if it was someone else case but the reason I run different versions of ZT is simply because of the versions availability for different OS'es. But the thing is I would have thought the newer version would be compatible with files generated by older version, not the other way around... and it is working for the mac client (even though I had to manually add the files + use the orbit command after), but I can't get the linux client to recognise the moons. Tried with and without leading zeros for the network, no change

To explain my setup a little :
Moons:
Root 1: Synology DSM 6.2 ZT 1.2.8r0 _(on which I generated the .moon config file)_
Root 2: RaspberryPi 3B+ Raspian Linux 4.14.79-v7+ ZT 1.2.12

Clients:
Client 1: macOS 10.14.1 ZT 1.2.12
Client 2: RaspberryPi 3B+ Raspian Linux 4.14.79-v7+ ZT 1.2.12

Edit: I also tried generating the .moon file on the root 2 (Raspberry with ZT 1.2.12) with same issue, mac client OK but RPi client only sees LEAF where it should be MOON

Edit 2: I picked a VPS now to try with a public static IP, clean machine. Debian Jessie, ZT version 1.2.12 and trying to make it a moon for the 2 clients just make the same result : mac client seen it as a MOON, the raspberry as a LEAF. I'll have a try on windows perhaps.
_Thing I noticed, when I compare the too answers to the listpeers command is that the moon is listed with /9993 port on the mac, but with a random /27811 port on the RPi_

stableEndpoints”: [ ] How to set it up? Domain name format is not supported

[adamierymenko]

Closing since moons are going to die.

[li2xi]

@adamierymenko Is moon going to be deprecated in the future? Are there any alternative solution for the area that can't get access to zerotier root server?