Vue-apollo: Loading is false using 'no-cache'

[eddivalen]

Why when I reload the page loading is false?
When I use fetchMore, loading changes to true, but on the first load, loading is false
I'm using 'no-cache' option

defaultOptions: {
    $query: {
      fetchPolicy: 'no-cache',
    },
  },

[internalfx]

I have the same issue...

[Akryum]

It seems to be an issue with Apollo Client.

[govert-w3s]

@Akryum Is this not an issue caused by the referenced commit (82d6c02f7b0202d7682007449dfce56de0f5f243)?

[eddivalen]

Hey @Akryum, what is the news with this issue? what do you suggest for those who use the no-cache option

[tobiasfuhlroth]

Related to https://github.com/vuejs/vue-apollo/issues/263?

[idflood]

I reproduced the issue with the vue-apollo e2e test. If you add the :fetch-policy="'no-cache'" to the ApolloQuery here

After this change, running the npm run test:e2e:dev:client will show this error:

So this check mentionned here by michael-harrison on "no-cache" was added here: https://github.com/vuejs/vue-apollo/pull/280 and discussed here https://github.com/vuejs/vue-apollo/commit/82d6c02f7b0202d7682007449dfce56de0f5f243 . I'm still not sure it this is the cause of the issue, but disabling the loading state to prevent an issue with optimistic response of no-cache queries seems strange.

Edit: commenting the mentionned condition is enough to fix the isLoading in the ApolloQuery component but the result.loading is still always false.

[idflood]

Starting to wonder if this is an issue with apollo client.

The shouldNotifyIfLoading condition here don't seem to set the loading property if the fetch policy is no-cache or network-only.

Setting notifyOnNetworkStatusChange does indeed seems to "fix" the issue.

Reading a bit more it seems that the loading state is a recurring issue with apollo-client (https://github.com/apollographql/react-apollo/issues/727#issuecomment-306082518 and https://github.com/apollographql/react-apollo/issues/2238 for example), which all suggest setting the notifyOnNetworkStatusChange to fix this.

[MJoshua25]

Any update?

[vlodko]

any luck?