Vscode: Install extension ranking is bad

Created on 1 Jun 2016  路  7Comments  路  Source: microsoft/vscode

It's sorting the partial matches by install count, regardless of relevance.

image

bug candidate extensions verified

Most helpful comment

This is also harmful imo as lesser known niche extensions will never get installed unless they're found via browsing the web interface.

All 7 comments

This is also harmful imo as lesser known niche extensions will never get installed unless they're found via browsing the web interface.

+1, the only way to get more audience for now is more downloads, which makes extensions less detectable.

Speaking of relevance, do we need to implement some special alogrithm to define relevance? For instance, when people search for php extensions, a debugger+intellisense extensions is more relevant than a theming extension, regardless of the name.

The marketplace has implemented a relevance sort order. We can jump onto it. Here are some query results, for reference.

A good one:

screen shot 2016-06-02 at 09 53 02

An OK one:

screen shot 2016-06-02 at 09 53 21

Hmm:

screen shot 2016-06-02 at 09 53 11

You can get the same results by running a search in the marketplace page.

If we do the jump, we should make sure the relevance is better tuned.

What about _expanding_ the Install Extension command, creating commands for each _Category_?

This way, the user could search specifically for Themes, Languages, Debuggers, etc, and its category could be applied as the first filter, regardles the relevance criteria that already exists.

I think this should be dealt with sooner rather than later, right now the installation advice given on the marketplace is wrong because of this. Consider https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=AdamCaviness.theme-monokai-dark-soda

image

image

Oh that's a much worse problem! #7327

Verification: search for extensions, they should not be sorted by download count.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings