Vm: Nextcloud Production Version / Misleading script name

[smartens]

Steps to reproduce

1. Use nextcloud_install_production.sh to install Nextcloud

Expected behaviour

The script name is misleading. I was searching for an install script which installs the production channel version of nextcloud (https://nextcloud.com/release-channels/). Nextcloud is offering on Docker hub the production/stable version 19.0.4 (https://hub.docker.com/_/nextcloud).

Actual behaviour

Instead of installing the production version the script installs the latest version.

Fetching the latest Nextcloud version...
20.0.1
Downloading nextcloud-20.0.1...

[enoch85]

Thanks for your issue. :+1:

It's made for production, and installs the latest version of Nextcloud.

The scripts itself is production ready, is the VM. I run all my Nextcloud servers with the latest version and have done so for years. The first maintenance version of a major version is what's usually solving the "bad" bugs, and running 20.0.1 in production is no issue at all if you ask me.

What Docker choose to call it is up to them, here we do what's been working for years.

I hope that answers your question. :robot:

[smartens]

Sure. I see your point. But it's not Docker who is choosing this name. It's the nextcloud team. Further, this repo is incorporated into the official nextcloud github account so I was 100% sure that it will align with the naming scheme the nextcloud team is using.

[szaimen]

@smartens I wonder where did you hear that 19.0.4 is the latest production release and not 20.0.1?

[enoch85]

He's right in the sense that the "production" train is one major version behind.

But as I said it's not not production just because it's 20.0.1.

Sent from ProtonMail, encrypted email based in Switzerland.

-------- Originalmeddelande --------
På 17 nov. 2020 22:49, szaimen skrev:

@smartens I wonder where did you hear that 19.0.4 is the latest production release and not 20.0.1?

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

[smartens]

But as I said it's not not production just because it's 20.0.1.

I just wanted to give feedback. It's not that I say your setup is not production ready.

I'm just trying to say that if somebody visits the nextcloud website, informs him/herself about nextcloud, finds out that they have a production release channel, goes to github and finds your repo, will think that it will install the production release channel version of nextcloud.

[enoch85]

It's noted.

Thanks for your input!