Trinitycore: DB/GameObject: Hallow's End achievement Tricks and Treats of ...

[BahDumbBugs]

Description: Tricks and Treats of Kalimdor World Event Achievement list includes Silverwind Refuge in Ashenvale when in some previous version, that particular candy bucket was pulled. (See photo) Cannot locate candy bucket in this commit,

Current behaviour: Player runs around Silverwind Refuge in circles searching for a candy bucket that is not there. (Not sure if it is SUPPOSED to be there, or if its supposed to be off the achievement list.)

Expected behaviour: If it supposed to be off the list, one shouldn't be directed to search for the Candy bucket in Silverwind Refuge. If there is supposed to be a bucket there, it's not. :)

Steps to reproduce the problem:

1. Work toward Tricks and Treats of Kalimdor Achievement
2. Fly or .tele to Silverwind Refuge.
3. Look for candy bucket.
4. Give up and update TC / Github.

Further investigation reveals that someone up and quit placing these candy buckets as they are missing in the remainder of the camps in Kalimdor. To be specific they are:

1) Grol'dom Farm
2) Hellscream's Watch
3) Camp Ataya
4) Stonemaul Hold
5) Bilgewater Harbor
6) Nozzlepot's Outpost
7) Desolation Hold
8) Krom'gar Fortress
9) Zoram'gar Outpost
10) Karnum's Glade (Horde AND Alliance)
11) Whisperwind Grove
12) Bootlegger Outpost
13) Marshal's Stand

Branch(es): 6.x - Have not tried in 3.x yet

TC hash/commit: TrinityCore rev. c676e80 2016-09-29 23:30:47 +0200 (6.x branch) (Unix, Release, Static)

TDB version: 7.04

Operating system: Win 10

http://i.imgur.com/1rSDY1z.jpg

[BahDumbBugs]

After dealing a bit more with these Hallow's End quests and Achievements, I stumbled across a few curious glitches/bugs. In the 'Tricks and Treats of Outland' segment of the Achievement, there are only two that can't be completed right off the bat. Those are the two that have to do with whether you choose allegiance with Scryers or Aldors. I have not established reputation with either faction and will be testing it shortly. With these two, however, the pumpkins are there, they are selectable (depending on your friendly status) but it will not reward you with the 'Handful of Treats' and complete that segment of the quest. More to come......

[BahDumbBugs]

In Northrend:

Horde Side

1) The following camps/points are showing the Candy Buckets as a Daily Quest (Blue Question Mark above). They are present and selectable, but when the Handful of Treats dialogue box opens up, you cannot select "Complete Quest" to finish and receive rewards.

• Taunka'le Village,
• Vengeance Landing,
• Unu'pe, (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
• Venomspite,
• Camp Tunka'lo,
• Dalaran
  Legerdamain Lounge, (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
  Sunreaver's Sanctuary (Horde)
  Silver Enclave (Alliance)
  Underbelly (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
• Wyrmrest Temple, (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
• Moa'ki Harbor, (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
• Agmar's Hammer,
• Camp Winterhoof,
• New Agamand,
• Bouldercrag's Refuge, (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
• K3, (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
• Warsong Hold and
• Kamagua (Horde _AND_ Alliance)

Both Horde and Alliance Factions have been checked on this commit. This report is accurate as of (and for) this commit.

2) In Bor'gorok Outpost the Candy Bucket is in the middle of the Apple Bob tub. Slight location adjustment is necessary. Candy Bucket is correctly represented with a yellow Question Mark quest indicator and normal in behavior, however.

The remainder are fine. (7 in Northrend.)

[BahDumbBugs]

Cataclysm (I know not all areas are implemented yet. This is just for posterity):

• [ ] Nordrassil does not have a Candy Bucket present in its proper location.
• [ ] Oasis of Vir'sar has no Candy Bucket in its proper location.
• [ ] Deepholm (Not Implemented yet) - Cannot locate Candy Bucket in Temple of Earth
• [ ] Ramkahen does not have a Candy Bucket
• [ ] Grove of Aessina does not have a Candy Bucket
• [ ] Shrine of Aviana does not have a Candy Bucket
• [ ] Firebeard's Patrol (Alliance) does not have a candy bucket
• [ ] Thundermar (Alliance) does not have a candy bucket
• [ ] Darkbreak Cove (Alliance) does not have a candy bucket
• [ ] Victor's Point (Alliance)

[funjoker]

Well I'm on some Bucket decoration stuff ^^...
Might just take some time

[Kittnz]

@funjoker 335 or 7.x?

[funjoker]

7.x

[BahDumbBugs]

Cool. Good to see some planning going on. I'll continue to find the nasty bugs and squish em. :)

[MrSmite]

@funjoker 335 or 7.x?

7.x

Unfortunately these holidays are largely broken in 335 too. Will this be able to be backported?

[BahDumbBugs]

I should throw on 3.3.5 as well and do the same quests. Compare/contrast works/fixes/bugs

[Kittnz]

Everything in Northrend that is mentioned here works on 335. What exactly are you working on @funjoker ?

[Aokromes]

Maybe some cherry picks are missing on 7.x

[Kittnz]

And what exactly doesn't work on 335 @MrSmite ?

[funjoker]

Do Not take spawns of eastern kingdoms and kalimdor to 7.x. Cata fucked it up.

Atm i sniff all candy bucket decoration things.
Trying to make a proper List.

[Kittnz]

i think iv done that last year. got both kingdoms

[funjoker]

well didn't check yet :D atm just sniffing ^^

[funjoker]

Is it possible, that you only sniffed the Cata areas and not the whole kingdom?
atm i could only find decoration and bucket in Twilight Highlands

[funjoker]

seems like you only did Horde decoration :(

[Kittnz]

Well i didn't do anything for 7.x only 335.

[funjoker]

My work so far:

7.x GOs

• [x] Eastern Kingdoms _(provided when both done)_
  
  
  
  • [x] Alliance
  
  
  • [x] Horde
  
  
• [x] Kalimdor _(provided when both done)_
  
  
  
  • [x] Alliance
  
  
  • [x] Horde
  
  
• [x] Outland _(already done)_
  
  
  
  • [x] Alliance
  
  
  • [x] Horde
  
  
• [x] Northrend _(some Quests bugged/repeatable)_
  
  
  
  • [x] Alliance _(some Quests bugged/repeatable)_
  
  
  • [x] Horde _(some Quests bugged/repeatable)_
  
  
• [x] Cataclysm _(provided when both done)_
  
  
  
  • [x] Alliance
  
  
  • [x] Horde
  
  
• [x] Pandaria _(provided when both done)_
  
  
  
  • [x] Alliance
  
  
  • [x] Horde
  
  

[MrSmite]

And what exactly doesn't work on 335 @MrSmite ?

I was thinking of the quests to put out the fires in Goldshire. You can get the quests from the Matron but nothing spawns. I didn't realize there was a separate report for that bug.

[BahDumbBugs]

@Aokromes , @tkrokli Would it be more helpful or less to have all the Hallow's end glitches in one ticket?

[ghost]

That depends on how connected & how close they are, like if they are handled by the same script file, SAI script, database table etc. Keep issues separate if they don't affect the same NPC(s) or script.

[BahDumbBugs]

So the procedure of rolling all the Treat buckets issues like these are good? (Im telling myself "Yes - otherwise there'd be a lot of noise about it by now". :) )

[BahDumbBugs]

Alliance Side

Just so you are aware, Stormwind and Ironforge have ZERO Hallow's End decor showing for me. If I'm missing something, someone please tell me where the decor is so I can retract this and correct myself. The town is so stinking big, its hard for me to run by every corner. The Wickerman figures are not there, so I may be right in a way.

1) The following camps/points are showing the Candy Buckets as a Daily Quest (Blue Question Mark above). They are present and selectable, but when the Handful of Treats dialogue box opens up, you cannot select "Complete Quest" to finish and receive rewards.

Northrend

• [ ] Fizzcrank Airstrip
• [ ] Valiance Keep
• [ ] Fort Wildervar
• [ ] Star's Rest
• [ ] Westguard Keep
• [ ] Valgarde
• [ ] Frosthold

2) The following camps / points are not showing buckets at all.

Kalimdor

• [ ] Dolanaar
• [ ] Lor'danel
• [ ] Thal'darah Overlook
• [ ] Astranaar
• [ ] Nijel's Point
• [ ] Karnum's Glade (Horde _AND_ Alliance)
• [ ] Whisperwind Grove
• [ ] Talonbranch Glade
• [ ] Dreamer's Rest
• [ ] Fort Triumph
• [ ] Honor's Stand
• [ ] Northwatch Hold
• [ ] Farwatcher's Glen
• [ ] Northwatch Expedition Base Camp
• [ ] Windshear Hold
• [ ] Bootlegger Outpost
• [ ] Marshal's Stand

Eastern Kingdoms

• [ ] Kharanos
• [ ] Goldshire
• [ ] Thelsamar
• [ ] Menethil Harbor
• [ ] Lakeshire
• [ ] Wildhammer Keep
• [ ] Stormwind - The Commons
• [ ] Darkshire
• [ ] Sentinel Hill
• [ ] Refuge Point
• [ ] Nethergarde Keep
• [ ] Dragon's Mouth
• [ ] Surwich
• [ ] Fort Livingston
• [ ] The Harborage
• [ ] Stormfeather Outpost
• [ ] Chillwind Camp
• [ ] Swiftgear Station

Northrend

The remainder are fine. (Only 4 in Northrend.)

[Kittnz]

Give me a few examples of locations.

[MrSmite]

Give me a few examples of locations.

While not a blue ?, the candy buckets in Stormwind, Goldshire and Lakeshire allowed me to do them twice each on a Paladin and Hunter (though I doubt it's a class issue). After two completions I now do not see the ? anymore.

Based on wowwiki, these buckets should be a one-time thing.

[BahDumbBugs]

Exactly @MrSmite . Theyre a one time deal from what Ive gone through during years on retail. AFter I did them once, I always got the generic "Greetings Threepwood" message. @Kittnz - Alliance side I have not gotten to yet. I left that there as a placeholder. Wanted to focus on Horde side first. I momentarily digressed to 3.3.5 for a moment to test a few things before dinner. I'll have an update for Alliance side (and tests) shortly. :)

[BahDumbBugs]

@MrSmite - What commit are you using and version? Im getting hardly anything on Alliance side. (See list above) No treat buckets, and barely any Hallow's End decor.

[BahDumbBugs]

"While not a blue ?, the candy buckets in Stormwind, Goldshire and Lakeshire allowed me to do them twice each on a Paladin and Hunter (though I doubt it's a class issue). After two completions I now do not see the ? anymore."

@MrSmite What version was that? 6.x or 3.3.5?

[ghost]

@BahDumbBugs : MrSmite has usually focused on 3.3.5 in the past, but I don't know about now.

Myself, I was able to access the candy bucket in Falconwing Square 2 times in a row on commit https://github.com/TrinityCore/TrinityCore/commit/10ca86edc51be285a7381d35178da10686eb88ee , my TC rev. hash before I pushed the commit to fix the quest "Completing the Delivery". Not tested after.

[MrSmite]

@BahDumbBugs

I'm using https://github.com/TrinityCore/TrinityCore/commit/2db9269ec1c06b5fccc45dc0a5b4f714f9b48804 with DB TDB_full_world_335.61_2016_04_11.sql + updates (because I'm revamping two patches I submitted a long time ago).

On that revision I can access the candy buckets 2 times per character per login (eg: it resets after I log out) and they only display the standard yellow "?".

[Kittnz]

I think that changed not too long ago

[BahDumbBugs]

Checking all Candy Buckets on my commit is complete. I don't know how we can verify all these treat buckets short of going through them one by one. Is there any way we can validate all these issues existing for the treat buckets? Please let me know if I am wrong on any of these or missed anything. Thanks!

[BahDumbBugs]

@MrSmite - I think @Kittnz is right. I can park at an inn with a blue question mark, try to get it - log out and come back and it will still show blue.

[Kittnz]

Either way, this is about 7.x not 3.3.5.

[funjoker]

Check this:

18134

[jerbookins]

f909d4f1957b

No Candy Bucket quests work.

Edit: I just took a peek at the server log and realized this is coming up when I try to complete the Candy Bucket quests

Error in QUEST_STATUS_COMPLETE: player Proteger (guid 4) tried to complete quest 12336, but is not allowed to do so (possible packet-hacking or high latency)