Terraform: AWS provider: aws_s3_bucket resource; missing versioning, lifecycle, logging, etc

[packplusplus]

AWS s3 APIs support several feature missing the aws_s3_bucket resource.

Terraform does not provide a way to;

• Turn on / off versioning
• Lifecycle control policies
• Logging targets
• Turn on / off Requestor pays
• Cross region replication
• Events

Versioning and lifecycle policies are the features I'm most interested in, but I was trying to be complete (like the format in #3096 h/t: @clstokes )

[ghost]

+1

[tisba]

This would be a feature we are interested in as well. We have lots of buckets that have at least one lifecycle policy and it's a pain to manage them via AWS Console (or API) after a TF run :-/

[tecnobrat]

+1 on events, we need this for our implementation.

[sstarcher]

+1 lifecyle

[mseiwald]

+1 lifecyle

[rmldsky]

+1 lifecycle

[scalp42]

I also don't believe you can create a bucket in a specific region (unless I'm wrong).

[cordoval]

buckets are created globally as per amazon

[packplusplus]

Buckets are namespaced globally, but you can indicate which region you want the data stored in. See documentation.

[scalp42]

That's what I meant by region sorry as in "cant tell Terraform to use us-west-2" for example.

[brikis98]

+1 for lifecycle

[chrisferry]

+1 for lifecycle.

[ben-nz]

+1 for lifecycle

[amuraru]

:+1:

[iulian-radu]

+1. See also: #4120

[failshell]

missing region as well.

+1 for logging.

[jasonyoumans]

+1 for lifecycle

[ktseytlin]

+1 for versioning/lifecycle/logging

[ecneladis]

+1 logging

f2ce28ed469b08874bdfaa6195c479754a6130e5: Add support for S3 logging

[jen20]

Hi all. Thanks for commenting. As of the latest released version (0.6.9) versioning is supported (https://www.terraform.io/docs/providers/aws/r/s3_bucket.html).

In addition, logging support is on the master branch and will form part of the next release, though you can build from source now (clone; make updatedeps, make bin) the meantime assuming you have a Go environment.

Lifecycle policies, requestor pays, cross region replication and events are not yet supported - we will aim to support them soon but have a decent backlog of issues and pull requests to get through at the moment. If anyone wants to take these on in the meantime, either myself or @catsby should be able to review and merge.

[nagas]

+1

[kingpong]

+1 cross-region replicaton

[dabdine-r7]

+1 events

[davido-bs]

+1 lifecycle

[curena]

+1 events

[egoldschmidt]

+1 events, lifecycle

[ruippeixotog]

+1 lifecycle

[conorgil]

+1 events

[gtmtech]

+1 cross-region replication

[panda87]

+1 for lifecycle

[JetStreamPilot]

+1 for lifecycle

[steve-jansen]

@packplusplus would you please strike log targets and versioning?

Believe both features shipped.

Cheers!

[netflash]

+1 cross-region replication / lifecycle

[saswatp]

+1 cross-region
+1 life-cycle

[jbiel]

I am very interested in being able to manage s3 lifecycle policies with Terraform.

[eyespies]

+1 cross-region
+1 lifecycle

[alfonso-cabrera]

+1 for cross region replication

[davidblewett]

+1 lifecycle

[aviflax]

+1 lifecycle please!

[ajlanghorn]

+1 lifecycle!

[radeksimko]

See S3 lifecycle PR in https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/6220

Feel free to post any feedback related to the implementation there ^

[stack72]

Lifecycle PR (#6220) has been merged

Can someone summate what is still missing from this issue? @packplusplus ?

[packplusplus]

I updated the original issue with strike thrus (good idea @steve-jansen).

@stack72 do you want to see these issues split out so you can wrestle them better, or do you like it in one place to point to?

What's left:

• Turn on / off Requestor pays - Not hugely important, I was just trying to highlight what wasn't supported that existed in aws. No one has +1'd
• Cross region replication - Seems pretty popular. Also seems hard, there are IAM components that would have to be either auto created or called out in docs.
• Events - Also seems popular. covered by pull/5473

[stack72]

nice summation @packplusplus - let's leave this issue as the main place right now :)

[hectcastro]

Are event notifications covered by https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/pull/5473? Also, I think adding support for toggling the newly added transfer acceleration feature would be great (landed in the Go SDK yesterday: https://github.com/aws/aws-sdk-go/commit/174327fecba83be58dea4dee0ef1599652e0f2e5):

• https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/aws/aws-storage-update-amazon-s3-transfer-acceleration-larger-snowballs-in-more-regions/
• http://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/API/RESTBucketGETaccelerate.html
• http://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/API/RESTBucketPUTaccelerate.html

[stack72]

Hi all

I just split the last 2 remaining items out into #7490 and #7491

Thanks

Paul

[hashibot[bot]]

I'm going to lock this issue because it has been closed for _30 days_ ⏳. This helps our maintainers find and focus on the active issues.

If you have found a problem that seems similar to this, please open a new issue and complete the issue template so we can capture all the details necessary to investigate further.