Syncthing-android: version number of syncthing-android has non-obvious relationship to syncthing version

Created on 23 May 2016  路  6Comments  路  Source: syncthing/syncthing-android

I use syncthing on android (from f-droid) and on NetBSD and OS X (from pkgsrc). Given that syncthing breaks protocol compatibility across major releases, this means that I have to upgrade everything at once. With syncthing proper, it's clear that 0.12.19 to 0.13.2 is a protocol change. In syncthing-android, going from 0.7.17 to 0.7.18 breaks protocol compatibility, if I read the commit logs correctly. I realize that most of the android code may not have changed, but it would be really nice to somehow change the version number in a louder way. One approach would be to just move to 0.8 for 0.13 (or 0.14 at this point).

question frozen-due-to-age

Most helpful comment

In my opinion it would make sense to mirror the major.minor version of the syncthing binary we use, e.g. now 0.13.x, where as x is unrelated to the syncthing binary.

All 6 comments

Syncthing and syncthing-android are seperate projects. I don't think it's feasible to sync the releases, because it would be a lot of extra effort.

But I see your point about breaking changes. I think it would be okay to increase the minor version in that case (so 0.7 to 0.8).

In my opinion it would make sense to mirror the major.minor version of the syncthing binary we use, e.g. now 0.13.x, where as x is unrelated to the syncthing binary.

Or 0.8.1.001302

Understood about separate projects and that synchronized releases would be too hard. I really only wanted to ask that when I saw a syncthing-android update that changes the syncthing branch (and hence is not protocol compatible) that it be readily apparent.

@capi Yeah that would make sense.

@AudriusButkevicius Looks way too complicated imo.

I think this can be closed now that the new release was labeled 0.8.0. Thanks for listening and adjusting the versioning scheme

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

reverse-unina picture reverse-unina  路  3Comments

oniGino picture oniGino  路  8Comments

klausenbusk picture klausenbusk  路  9Comments

daradib picture daradib  路  8Comments

alerque picture alerque  路  6Comments