Streetcomplete: 17.0beta2 crashes on vegetarian quest

[peternewman]

Trying to complete vegetarian quest closes app.

How to Reproduce

Versions affected

17.0beta2
Android 9

[westnordost]

Do you use the Google Play version? No crash report reached me so far. Also I cannot reproduce it.

Is it reproducible for you? And what about the vegan quest?

[peternewman]

Do you use the Google Play version? No crash report reached me so far. Also I cannot reproduce it.

Yes I do. Telford Service station in the UK does it.

Is it reproducible for you? And what about the vegan quest?

Yes, haven't tried vegan yet.

[westnordost]

So you mean, you can reproduce it but only exactly at one place? Can you tell me the location of that place?

[peternewman]

https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/4849911834#map=18/52.67701/-2.39945

[peternewman]

I can't get a vegan quest up there to test it and I'm struggling to find another to check that.

[westnordost]

Hmm, I also can't reproduce it there.

Do you have auto-sync on or off? Does it happen immediately after you tapped the answer?

[peternewman]

It's just that node, vegan and vegetarian work elsewhere for me. This feels like the crossing thing I had before which was only cleared by clearing my cache.

[peternewman]

Hmm, I also can't reproduce it there.

Do you have auto-sync on or off? Does it happen immediately after you tapped the answer?

WiFi only.

Sooner, the moment I tap the quest icon it bombs out before I even get a chance to answer.

[westnordost]

Oh, that's different! What language do you use on your phone, en-GB?

[peternewman]

Oh, that's different! What language do you use on your phone, en-GB?

Yes

[westnordost]

Hmm, even still can't reproduce it.
Well tomorrow latest I should see the crash report in the developer area in Google Play, we'll see.

[westnordost]

No related crash report turned up. Can you reproduce this bug still with the beta3?

[westnordost]

If yes, could you please download the APK from here https://github.com/westnordost/StreetComplete/releases/download/v17.0-beta3/StreetComplete-v17.0-beta3.apk ? When this APK crashes, it will prompt you to send the crash report directly to me via Email.

[HolgerJeromin]

I installed the apk (over play store 16.x) and got this:

No way to open the app

[westnordost]

What, with beta3??

[HolgerJeromin]

With the linked apk

[westnordost]

Phew. I also downloaded the linked APK but could not reproduce any crash. If it crashes right on start-up, of course it is not possible for you to send me any email through this app.

But anyway, this is a different problem as the one discussed here. @HolgerJeromin , could we either continue tracking this problem via email or via a new ticket please? My email is [email protected].
The next thing I would be asking you is to uninstall the app and reinstall it, see if it still crashes then. This way I know at least if the crash happens due to some configuration made.

[peternewman]

No related crash report turned up. Can you reproduce this bug still with the beta3?

No it doesn't seem to any more thanks. Do you think you found the cause of it, or is it likely to have just been some cache thing that got chased away?

[westnordost]

No idea. You said that it always happened for this one quest, exactly when opening it. No bug that I fixed (or for that matter, nothing that I changed for v17) had anything to do the the veg quest or any quest form being displayed. So,... no idea, but if it is gone now, let's close it and we will see if the bug occurs later on.