Streetcomplete: New quest: Add name to bus stops/trams

[rugk]

Bus stops should always have a name. Because otherwise you cannot search for bus stops on the map, which makes them quite useless.

• [x] Easy to answer, i.e. everyone can easily solve it (from the outside)
• [x] Easy user interface. (similar to streetname quest)
• [x] Has a useful purpose. (bus stops are useless without it, see above)
• [x] Established tag. (name is established, of course)
• [x] Low unanswerable quests. (i.e. low false positives; bus stops should have a street sign in all countries)
• [x] It can be determined, if the quest is needed to be asked. (Yes, if the name is not set.)

However…

• [ ] the quest applies to a reasonable number of things (i.e. is not a small quest, whcih can only be found in one city) – I am not sure about this, as I don't know how common is this "defect" of a missing for such an object is.

Issue idea by @chrisdebian, original issue https://github.com/westnordost/StreetComplete/issues/548

[rugk]

Of course, this also applies to trams.

[westnordost]

Not sure what you mean with the last checkbox, I see no problem there. Generally, all/most bus stops across most countries have names.

[rugk]

I just mean that maybe the problem this quest tackles is really small (in your new checklist that is the "Applies to a reasonable number of elements"): Because are not all bus stops on OSM mostly correctly mapped with a name on it? Is there even a reasonable number of bus stops without a name?

I am not sure about this…

[westnordost]

About 400000 bus stops currently have no name

[rugk]

I have no idea how you got this number, but that is more than enough to be worth a quest.

[westnordost]

https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/highway=bus_stop#combinations

Total highway=bus_stop: 1918159
highway=bus_stop with name=*: 1573134

(And that's only highway=bus_stop)

[dbdean]

This would fall under https://github.com/westnordost/StreetComplete/issues/309, right? And have the same translation problems?

[westnordost]

Hm`? Usually, bus stops are not that close to each other that you can mistake one for the other.

[dbdean]

Not that there would be bus stop confusion, but that it would make sense to roll this into the general 'What is the name of this {object}?" quest, rather than having a separate name quest for bus stops. And that that quest is blocked by the translation issue.

[rugk]

I think a specific quest would make sense – even if it is just for the different (more appropriate) icon. I see no translation issue when you just ask "What is the name of this bus stop?" for this quest.

[PanierAvide]

Still something that should be done ? We have an interest for a local group of having a quest for setting bus stop names, so I can work on this.

[westnordost]

No, it can be implemented.