Status-react: New invite to group chat will be not sent if user left chat and then will be readded

Created on 21 Apr 2020  路  6Comments  路  Source: status-im/status-react

Bug Report

Problem

Currently, we have odd behavior after user left and was readded by admin - chat is not recreated and user doesn't receive the invite.
As a user, I want to be warned that if I left chat - it is forever and I can't be added to the same group again if this behavior is expected.

Expected behavior

User is warned about consequences

Actual behavior

User can be added but doesn't receive the invite

Reproduction

  • As user A: create group chat with User B
  • As User B: join to group chat
  • As User B: left group chat
  • As User A: add User B to the same group chat again

Additional Information

  • Status version: release v.1.3
  • Operating System: Android, iOS
bug group-chat

All 6 comments

@hesterbruikman would like to have your opinion on this, thank you!

Agree, that's unexpected behavior. Seems more like user B's action is abandon instead of leave. So either we can think of copy changes to better reflect what happens or allow re-adding. @cammellos can you please explain why a user cannot be re-added after leaving a group chat?

User can be re-added to a chat from a technical perspective,I think it's just a choice we have to make, no technical reason to be one way or the other.

it shouldn't be a one-way street: one of admins removes a user, anyone who's a group admin can choose to add him back, the same flow is repeated again when the user was added for the first time. there's no limit in place on how many times a user can be removed and invited back, the same goes for leaving the chat by the user

cool, we can change the behavior

@cammellos thank you!

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

chadyj picture chadyj  路  92Comments

jeluard picture jeluard  路  68Comments

churik picture churik  路  52Comments

pedropombeiro picture pedropombeiro  路  63Comments

lukaszfryc picture lukaszfryc  路  117Comments