Solidus: Heroku Button (for demo) Fails on Build

[graygilmore]

The Heroku button in the Readme is currently broken.

-----> Fetching set buildpack https://github.com/solidusio/heroku-buildpack-solidus-demo.git... done
-----> Ruby app detected
-----> Compiling Ruby/Rails
       Compiling solidus
### SNIPPED CODE
20 gems installed
/app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/rubygems/dependency.rb:319:in `to_specs': Could not find 'railties' (~> 4.2.0) - did find: [railties-5.0.0] (Gem::LoadError)
Checked in 'GEM_PATH=/app/vendor/bundle/ruby/2.3.0:/app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/gems/2.3.0', execute `gem env` for more information
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/rubygems/dependency.rb:328:in `to_spec'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_gem.rb:65:in `gem'
    from -e:1:in `<main>'
logger: unrecognized option '--skip-bundle'
### SNIPPED CODE
 !
 !     " new sandbox --skip-bundle --database=postgresql" failed
 !
/tmp/buildpack20160705-159-ts13py/lib/language_pack/solidus.rb:88:in `sh': " new sandbox --skip-bundle --database=postgresql" failed (RuntimeError)
    from /tmp/buildpack20160705-159-ts13py/lib/language_pack/solidus.rb:29:in `compile'
### SNIPPED TRACE
 !     Push rejected, failed to compile Ruby app

[jasonfb]

strange, that looks like a rubygems.org problem. Does bundle install on the very same app work locally?

[jasonfb]

there definitely is a rubygem for railties at the exact version 4.2.0. are you sure your Gemfile has specified rubygems.org as the source?

I see now you wrote "Heroku Button". I don't really know what that does exactly and Solidus is likely too complicated to deploy with button. I'd try to make yourself a brand new app and see if you can re-create the problem on it.

[graygilmore]

This is in reference to the Deploy with Heroku button on the main page of this repo.

[jasonfb]

Oh ok, got it now. My opinion is that button should just go. Deploying with a button isn't such a great idea and is not something that is going to be consistent and easy to support. (I don't know why Heroku encourages it, it's really not a such good idea). Seems like it breaks often, and Heroku's build procedure changes too, and moving forward this button is just a headache.

We maintain a fresh install app ("hello world") app here: http://solidus-1-3-helloworld.herokuapp.com

I can modify this helloworld app with the latest released version and also make a new one for 1.4 now.

[graygilmore]

As far as I know the idea behind the button is just to try it out, not to actually start work on a new project.

[jasonfb]

Yes I hear ya, it's just that this is the umpteenth time I've seen people have problems with it and Heroku has the power to change stuff on their side and break the button (which admittedly, happens rarely, but can happen). All I'm saying is that supporting it seems untenable to me.

[marknfischer]

I had same issue last week and today with this button. Would love to "try it out with the click of a button." I'm obviously not going into production with that architecture. But seeing it working w/o spinning up a local rails instance would be awesome.

[cassidyclawson]

Just another +1 that the button doesn't work. I think ya'll show try to save it because the button is a great way for people like me to demo the app.

[dfranciosi]

I can confirm that it doesn't work yet
could not connect to server: No such file or directory (PG::ConnectionBad) Is the server running locally and accepting connections on Unix domain socket "/var/run/postgresql/.s.PGSQL.5432"?

[michaelminter]

I get

Bundle completed (39.73s)
       Cleaning up the bundler cache.
 !
 !     cannot load such file -- bundler/lockfile_parser
 !
/app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:55:in `require': cannot load such file -- bundler/lockfile_parser (LoadError)
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:55:in `require'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/helpers/bundler_wrapper.rb:128:in `block in parse_gemfile_lock'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:18:in `block (2 levels) in instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:40:in `yield_with_block_depth'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:17:in `block in instrument'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/benchmark.rb:308:in `realtime'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:16:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/helpers/bundler_wrapper.rb:85:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/helpers/bundler_wrapper.rb:126:in `parse_gemfile_lock'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/helpers/bundler_wrapper.rb:110:in `lockfile_parser'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/helpers/bundler_wrapper.rb:73:in `specs'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/helpers/bundler_wrapper.rb:53:in `has_gem?'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/ruby.rb:659:in `block in create_database_yml'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:18:in `block (2 levels) in instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:40:in `yield_with_block_depth'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:17:in `block in instrument'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/benchmark.rb:308:in `realtime'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:16:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:48:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:44:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/ruby.rb:657:in `create_database_yml'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/ruby.rb:102:in `block (2 levels) in compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/ruby.rb:751:in `allow_git'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/ruby.rb:98:in `block in compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:18:in `block (2 levels) in instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:40:in `yield_with_block_depth'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:17:in `block in instrument'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/benchmark.rb:308:in `realtime'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:16:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:48:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:44:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/ruby.rb:88:in `compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/rails2.rb:49:in `block in compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:18:in `block (2 levels) in instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:40:in `yield_with_block_depth'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:17:in `block in instrument'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/benchmark.rb:308:in `realtime'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:16:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:48:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:44:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/rails2.rb:47:in `compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/rails3.rb:38:in `block in compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:18:in `block (2 levels) in instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:40:in `yield_with_block_depth'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:17:in `block in instrument'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/benchmark.rb:308:in `realtime'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:16:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:48:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:44:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/rails3.rb:37:in `compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/rails4.rb:41:in `block in compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:18:in `block (2 levels) in instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:40:in `yield_with_block_depth'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:17:in `block in instrument'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/benchmark.rb:308:in `realtime'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:16:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:48:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:44:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/rails4.rb:40:in `compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/solidus.rb:66:in `compile'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/bin/compile:16:in `block (2 levels) in <main>'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/base.rb:131:in `log'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/bin/compile:15:in `block in <main>'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:35:in `block in trace'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:18:in `block (2 levels) in instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:40:in `yield_with_block_depth'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:17:in `block in instrument'
    from /app/vendor/ruby-2.3.1/lib/ruby/2.3.0/benchmark.rb:308:in `realtime'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:16:in `instrument'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/lib/language_pack/instrument.rb:35:in `trace'
    from /app/tmp/buildpacks/4503e3a76977915f47253edc22ff766cf41874cec155814eeb2bed137037cc920729733d948ffeb2124e6612e9bfcc160ea3849de67fe7190e0f7d126454c288/bin/compile:11:in `<main>'
 !     Push rejected, failed to compile Ruby app.
 !     Push failed

[sheerun]

Confirming

[nhodges]

Now it fails because of interdependency issues.

Gemfile requires rails (= 4.2.7.1) however the version of solidus_core it resolves to requires rails (~> 5.0.0)

Why not point the Heroku template at the latest working release?

https://heroku.com/deploy?template=https://github.com/solidusio/solidus/tree/v1.4.0.beta1

Edit: Tried that and ran into the issue @michaelminter is facing regarding bundler/lockfile_parser not loading for whatever reason.

[jhawthorn]

This should be fixed!

I can't thank @stewart enough for fixing the issues with bundler and updating the buildpack to rails 5.