Signal-android: Throttle notifications

Created on 23 Jun 2017  路  5Comments  路  Source: signalapp/Signal-Android

Notifications for incoming messages are not throttled at the moment. This means that the phone makes a sound or vibration for each and every incoming message, even if they are just seconds apart. I feel like a slave to the phone because it grabs my attention constantly when I'm in the middle of something else. It breaks my concentration.

At the same time, I do want to receive notifications. Just not so many.

I propose:

  1. Notify the user at most once every X minutes (default: 15 minutes?) after the last notification or after the last time the user opened Signal. There is no point in telling the user many times that messages are available.
  2. Notify about an incoming message not immediately but after 1 minute delay. That way multiple incoming messages can be read in one go instead of being constantly forced to either monitor the chat or be distracted by the notifications. I think this feature must be default off because it adds a delay that users might not expect. I'm not sure.

The delay constants should be configurable to adapt the app to users diverse needs. I hope this feature request makes sense for the product. I'm using Google Android 7.1 and Windows 7 with Signal Desktop.

Most helpful comment

I'm in a Signal Desktop chat right now. Literally, every few seconds my phone buzzes immediately when Desktop receives a message. It also buzzes for each and every message. I basically want to be notified by new messages meaning I can't just disable notifications. I have no mitigation against my phone constantly buzzing.

@Signal Team: Can you prioritize this? You have built a very fine messenger, and it's free, but this notification spam is quite a problem.

I also wonder: Is the team themselves not annoyed by this when they use Signal? Maybe most team members have disabled notifications or are using some configuration or communication style where it's not a problem. Maybe the team is therefore not aware enough of this issue because of their own usage patterns. That's why I'm pinging this issue.

All 5 comments

My idea for dealing with this: #6288

I'm in a Signal Desktop chat right now. Literally, every few seconds my phone buzzes immediately when Desktop receives a message. It also buzzes for each and every message. I basically want to be notified by new messages meaning I can't just disable notifications. I have no mitigation against my phone constantly buzzing.

@Signal Team: Can you prioritize this? You have built a very fine messenger, and it's free, but this notification spam is quite a problem.

I also wonder: Is the team themselves not annoyed by this when they use Signal? Maybe most team members have disabled notifications or are using some configuration or communication style where it's not a problem. Maybe the team is therefore not aware enough of this issue because of their own usage patterns. That's why I'm pinging this issue.

@GSPP Please don't bump issues. If the issue is open it's tracked.

GitHub Issue Cleanup:
See #7598 for more information.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

5boro picture 5boro  路  3Comments

derWalter picture derWalter  路  3Comments

gmsl360 picture gmsl360  路  3Comments

FeuRenard picture FeuRenard  路  3Comments

McLoo picture McLoo  路  3Comments