Sentry: Don't mark a resolved issue as regressed upon a report from a browser with an old release

Created on 19 Jul 2016  路  4Comments  路  Source: getsentry/sentry

Here's a proposal for dealing with obsolete releases:

  1. See a Sentry issue in Javascript
  2. Fix the bug
  3. Deploy the fix to production
  4. Mark the Sentry issue as resolved
  5. A user with a long-lived tab triggers the issue again

What happens: Sentry re-opens the issue as "regressed" even though it knows the report was from an obsolete release.

Expected: Sentry records the error, but does not re-open the issue unless further reports occur in an up-to-date release.

Most helpful comment

@dmnd Since you posted this, we've since introduced new features for choosing which releases the fix is introduced in (e.g. "Mark as resolved in "). Closing, but I'll re-open if you feel those changes don't address your concerns.

All 4 comments

This is def something we should figure out. It's basically "Resolved in [this|previous] release". It might make sense to make this the default resolved behavior, but than the complexity is if the error isn't a code error -- such as a database connection error -- it doesnt get resolved from code changes.

It's possible though in that same situation the logic of "ignore old releases" would be fine.

The only situation I can think of where "ignore old release" will hide legit errors is if you have a zombie worker process running old code due to a bad deploy. Maybe that's OK? Or maybe "ignore old releases" is javascript specific?

@dmnd Since you posted this, we've since introduced new features for choosing which releases the fix is introduced in (e.g. "Mark as resolved in "). Closing, but I'll re-open if you feel those changes don't address your concerns.

Thanks @benvinegar!

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

Aletz-Arce picture Aletz-Arce  路  3Comments

nickolaskraus-wf picture nickolaskraus-wf  路  3Comments

jmatsushita picture jmatsushita  路  4Comments

fatagun picture fatagun  路  4Comments

benvinegar picture benvinegar  路  4Comments