Salt: Salt-Cloud assesment: AWS is changing the Instance ID format, does have any impact?

Created on 14 Jan 2016 · 10Comments · Source: saltstack/salt

AWS just released a notification saying

We're transitioning instance IDs and reservation IDs to a longer format

AWS is transitioning instance IDs and reservation IDs to a longer format. 
The old format is a resource identifier followed by an 8-character string, and the new format is a resource identifier followed by a 17-character string. 
You have until December 2016 to opt in to the longer format.

If you do not take any action, you will be opted in automatically on December 2016, when all new instance IDs and Reservation IDs will be created with the longer format. 
Until the deadline, you can opt in and out of the new format as needed. 
Only newly created resources receive longer IDs; existing resources are unaffected.

Manage your transition to longer instance IDs and reservation IDs with Resource ID length management, and read more about the new format.

The new format is here

Question RIoT Salt-Cloud

Source

DanyC97

All 10 comments

I was wondering when Amazon would get around to doing that.

We'll want to double-check of course, but last I checked Salt Cloud doesn't care what the IDs actually look like, so long as they're there. This should not have any impact.

techhat on 14 Jan 2016

:+1: @techhat
I was thinking that is the case but thought a pair of eyes won't hurt.

DanyC97 on 14 Jan 2016

@DanyC97 and @techhat please see PR https://github.com/saltstack/salt/pull/30433, as it is related.

rallytime on 19 Jan 2016

Thanks @rallytime. I wasn't aware of that pillar. Do you know of any other regular expressions that have to do with AWS?

techhat on 19 Jan 2016

I don't. I just saw that PR come in today and remembered this issue. We should look around though...

rallytime on 19 Jan 2016

After an audit of the related aws code, and now that #30553 and #30433 have been merged, this issue has been resolved. Thanks for bringing it to our attention @DanyC97!

rallytime on 22 Jan 2016

Always a pleasure @rallytime :+1:

DanyC97 on 23 Jan 2016

It would appear that salt-cloud is still provisioning instances with short IDs in environments where long IDs are supported.

QuinnyPig on 26 Sep 2016

😕2

I'm unable to use salt-cloud. It's not working properly for long instance IDs and volume IDs.

ehrhardt on 26 Jan 2017

Works well here. What are you seeing?

On Jan 25, 2017, at 4:46 PM, Danilo E. F. Bento notifications@github.com wrote:

I'm unable to use salt-cloud. It's not working properly for long instance IDs and volume IDs.

—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

.

.