Roundcubemail: Nested conditioning skin markup behaves weirdly

[jfcherng]

Environment

• RC: official git repo here, master branch
• PHP: both 5.6.40 and 7.4.0-dev are tested with the same results

Problem

Since I don't see a note in Wiki that RC's skin markup does not allow doing this common template feature, I consider this as a bug.

=> outputs A C (Good)

=> outputs D (Bad, should be B C)

=> outputs B C D (Bad, should be D)

=> outputs B C D (Bad, should be D)

Reproducer

I replace the whole skins/elastic/templates/login.html with the following codes and visit the login page to do above tests.

<roundcube:if condition="0" />
    <roundcube:if condition="0" />
        A
    <roundcube:else />
        B
    <roundcube:endif />
        C
<roundcube:else />
    D
<roundcube:endif />

[alecpl]

This is indeed a limitation of our template engine. We should document that. Fixing this is not trivial and also not a high prio.

[vaso123]

This is a must have feature. Maybe that could be an option, if you should tag your condition with a name.

For example:

<roundcube:if condition="config:something_enabled=='1'" name="something" />
Say something here
    <roundcube:if condition="config:anything_enabled=='1'" name="anything" />
        Say anything here
    <roundcube:endif name="anything" />
    More something
<roundcube:endif name="something" />

It is insane that now I feel this template engine is good for nothing, and I always should use objects, mixing languages and do the HTML output from PHP.

[vaso123]

Ok guys, the best way is if you compelety change the roundcube engine. Absolutelly unusable.

Here is my solution.

https://github.com/vaso123/Twiggy/blob/master/twiggy.php

Use twig. My example of course only a skeleton, but you can improve it.

[jfcherng]

Personally I like Twig's functionality (but not it's syntax) since I have used it in several (Slim/Symfony) projects. But I don't think it would be used in official RC because it will just break every existing skin, which is a big BC break imo.

[alecpl]

Fixed.