Rocket.chat: Wrong German translation for "enter to"

Created on 9 Sep 2016  路  4Comments  路  Source: RocketChat/Rocket.Chat

Your Rocket.Chat version: 1.3.1 for Windows

When editing a sent message, the following messages appear in the corners of the edit window:

  • verlassen, um abbrechen
  • betreten, um 盲nderungen speichern

The words and the grammar are both wrong.

  • Instead of "verlassen", it should be "Escape" or "Esc", since this is about the keyboard key, not escaping from prison. The whole message should be "Esc, um abzubrechen". When starting a sentence with "Press a key to" in German, a following verb is modified, adding the zu syllable.
  • The other message should be "Enter, um nderungen zu speichern". In German, it looks weird to write nouns in lowercase.

To avoid these problems, translations should generally be done in complete sentences and not by combining parts of sentences. While it may work in English, the grammar of other languages is largely different.

bug

All 4 comments

Hey @rillig-nm,

i think you can fix this by yourself with "lingohub".

The Rocket.Chat team use that tool, to translate all the things to the language the users want.

@Sing-Li or @marceloschmidt Can give you more information about this.

I don't think I can fix this as a translator alone. If I were to translate "Cancel" with "abzubrechen" (as required in this case), it would become wrong in other places where "Abbrechen" is the correct translation. Therefore, this must be fixed in the code.

I have fixed this in Lingohub for the German language. I applied a shortened wording to circumvent the grammar problem:

Esc: Abbrechen
Enter-Taste: 脛nderungen speichern

Using "Key: meaning" should be very clear and not affect any other appearances. I recommend to translate that way also in other languages.

That looks great. Since this only affect these two keys, it was indeed simple. I just couldn't see it. :)

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

engelgabriel picture engelgabriel  路  3Comments

zeigerpuppy picture zeigerpuppy  路  3Comments

Kiran-Rao picture Kiran-Rao  路  3Comments

royalaid picture royalaid  路  3Comments

karlprieb picture karlprieb  路  3Comments