Rocket.chat.electron: Tray icon balloon in every closes of the mainwindow

[Albvadi]

My Setup

• Operating System: Windows 10
• App Version: 3.0.0
• Installation type: MSI
  
• [X] I have tested with the latest version
• [X] I can simulate the issue easily

Description

Tray icon balloon in every closes of the mainwindow

Current Behavior

Every time I close the mainwindow, a balloon it´s showed saying me that app is´still running. I know from the first notification that the application it´s still running in background,

Expected Behavior

I expect only one notification the first that I close the application´s mainwindow, but not all the times, same as other windows applications. If anything, the first time after every restart of the application process.

[thuguet]

I also have users complaining of that,
they would wan't to have the ability to disable this specific notification, but not the other one.

[stevenhfotofix]

Its extremely annoying, we need an option to remove this completely useless notification.

[Chealer]

This persists in 3.0.2. I recommend to pull version 3 until this is fixed.

[daztop]

Just to add to this - Skype shows a similar notification, but includes a message indicating that clicking the notification will dismiss it and not show again. I can't imagine why anyone would think it a good idea to show it every single time.

[Cancer-zern]

Windows 10 x64, version 3.0.4, exe installation, same issue

[DhruvParanjape]

can these lines be removed

https://github.com/RocketChat/Rocket.Chat.Electron/blob/0adc73c2ecfe7010adbb06583b22c55ff172a169/src/ui/main/trayIcon.ts#L122-L124

they are the source of this popup and it's win32 only and really annoying.

alternatively maybe add a setting to enable/disable this "feature" ?

[eduardhc]

can these lines be removed

https://github.com/RocketChat/Rocket.Chat.Electron/blob/0adc73c2ecfe7010adbb06583b22c55ff172a169/src/ui/main/trayIcon.ts#L122-L124

they are the source of this popup and it's win32 only and really annoying.

alternatively maybe add a setting to enable/disable this "feature" ?

More than removing, I'd say better just add a flag so it is only shown the first time the window is closed to tray. And serializing it somewhere, so it doesn't que get shown again on next app executions.

[DhruvParanjape]

can these lines be removed
https://github.com/RocketChat/Rocket.Chat.Electron/blob/0adc73c2ecfe7010adbb06583b22c55ff172a169/src/ui/main/trayIcon.ts#L122-L124

they are the source of this popup and it's win32 only and really annoying.
alternatively maybe add a setting to enable/disable this "feature" ?

More than removing, I'd say better just add a flag so it is only shown the first time the window is closed to tray. And serializing it somewhere, so it doesn't que get shown again on next app executions.

that would be great but if that's not something that will be built by the next release, I would suggest just disabling this and enabling it once we actually have a setting or option to disable it.

[stevenhfotofix]

can these lines be removed
https://github.com/RocketChat/Rocket.Chat.Electron/blob/0adc73c2ecfe7010adbb06583b22c55ff172a169/src/ui/main/trayIcon.ts#L122-L124

they are the source of this popup and it's win32 only and really annoying.
alternatively maybe add a setting to enable/disable this "feature" ?

More than removing, I'd say better just add a flag so it is only shown the first time the window is closed to tray. And serializing it somewhere, so it doesn't que get shown again on next app executions.

that would be great but if that's not something that will be built by the next release, I would suggest just disabling this and enabling it once we actually have a setting or option to disable it.

I have stopped my users from updating the client, until this is resolved. Yes, it is that big an issue for our team. I second @Dark-Passenger in just commenting it out until there is an official option (or just flat out deleted, our team used it perfectly well for years without being told that the window was still open - Heck, OSX does that by default for applications all the time, keeping the application running, even when the main window is closed, without the user having to be explicitly told so. They seem to manage fine.)

[RavuAlHemio]

Showing the message only once per execution is an improvement, but still a tad too annoying. Please improve this further, either by showing the message only once (and persisting the flag that stores that the user has seen this message before), as recommended by @eduardhc, or by providing a user preference to not display these messages at all, as recommended by @Dark-Passenger.

Thanks!