Respec: <aside role=dialog> fails spec-prod validation

Created on 20 Apr 2021 · 2Comments · Source: w3c/respec
Important info

URL to affected spec: https://w3c.github.io/media-source/, https://github.com/w3c/media-source/runs/2394585254
ReSpec version: Whatever spec-prod uses, probably v26.5.2.
[x] I did a "hard refresh", but it's still busted.
Description of problem

What happened (e.g., it crashed)?:
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2631.7-2631.171: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2631.7-2631.171: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2657.13-2657.189: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2657.13-2657.189: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2667.13-2667.175: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2667.13-2667.175: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2681.13-2681.178: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2681.13-2681.178: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2693.13-2693.174: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2693.13-2693.174: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2705.13-2705.176: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2705.13-2705.176: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2717.13-2717.187: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2717.13-2717.187: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2729.13-2729.186: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2729.13-2729.186: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2741.13-2741.184: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2741.13-2741.184: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2753.13-2753.189: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2753.13-2753.189: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2763.13-2763.193: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2763.13-2763.193: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2775.13-2775.205: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2775.13-2775.205: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2787.13-2787.187: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2787.13-2787.187: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2821.13-2821.183: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2821.13-2821.183: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2833.13-2833.191: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2833.13-2833.191: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2845.13-2845.193: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2845.13-2845.193: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2857.13-2857.193: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2857.13-2857.193: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2869.13-2869.197: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2869.13-2869.197: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2881.13-2881.203: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2881.13-2881.203: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2893.13-2893.189: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2893.13-2893.189: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2905.13-2905.207: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2905.13-2905.207: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2917.13-2917.211: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2917.13-2917.211: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2929.13-2929.197: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2929.13-2929.197: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2941.13-2941.206: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2941.13-2941.206: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2951.13-2951.179: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":2951.13-2951.179: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3021.13-3021.175: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3021.13-3021.175: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3035.13-3035.182: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3035.13-3035.182: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3047.13-3047.182: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3047.13-3047.182: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3059.13-3059.176: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3059.13-3059.176: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3071.13-3071.184: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3071.13-3071.184: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3083.13-3083.184: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3083.13-3083.184: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3095.13-3095.198: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3095.13-3095.198: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3107.13-3107.190: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3107.13-3107.190: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3119.13-3119.190: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3119.13-3119.190: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3131.13-3131.188: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3131.13-3131.188: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3143.13-3143.202: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3143.13-3143.202: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3155.13-3155.198: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3155.13-3155.198: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3167.13-3167.194: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3167.13-3167.194: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3179.13-3179.184: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3179.13-3179.184: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3191.13-3191.190: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3191.13-3191.190: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3203.13-3203.182: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3203.13-3203.182: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3215.13-3215.182: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3215.13-3215.182: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3227.13-3227.192: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3227.13-3227.192: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3239.13-3239.178: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3239.13-3239.178: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3251.13-3251.180: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3251.13-3251.180: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3263.13-3263.175: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3263.13-3263.175: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3273.13-3273.193: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3273.13-3273.193: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3283.13-3283.189: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3283.13-3283.189: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3293.13-3293.193: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3293.13-3293.193: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3303.13-3303.193: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3303.13-3303.193: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3313.13-3313.189: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3313.13-3313.189: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3323.13-3323.188: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3323.13-3323.188: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3333.13-3333.202: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3333.13-3333.202: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3343.13-3343.204: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3343.13-3343.204: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3353.13-3353.206: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3353.13-3353.206: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3363.13-3363.188: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3363.13-3363.188: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3373.13-3373.196: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3373.13-3373.196: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3383.13-3383.206: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3383.13-3383.206: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3393.13-3393.202: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3393.13-3393.202: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3403.13-3403.212: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3403.13-3403.212: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3413.13-3413.225: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3413.13-3413.225: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3423.13-3423.187: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3423.13-3423.187: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3441.13-3441.184: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3441.13-3441.184: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3451.13-3451.184: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3451.13-3451.184: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3463.13-3463.206: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3463.13-3463.206: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3475.13-3475.212: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3475.13-3475.212: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3487.13-3487.184: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3487.13-3487.184: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3497.13-3497.190: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3497.13-3497.190: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3511.13-3511.190: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3511.13-3511.190: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3525.13-3525.189: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3525.13-3525.189: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3539.13-3539.208: error: Bad value “dialog” for attribute “role” on element “aside”.
    "file:/home/runner/work/media-source/media-source.w3c/index.html":3539.13-3539.208: error: Attribute “aria-modal” not allowed on element “aside” at this point.
  ❌  Not so good... please fix the issues above.
  Error: Process completed with exit code 1.
Expected behavior (e.g., it shouldn't crash): It shouldn't cause errors
I think this is a regression from https://github.com/w3c/respec/pull/3458, while it could just be a validator bug.
bug
Source
saschanaz
Most helpful comment

Regression. Spoke to the ARIA in HTML editors yesterday and they suggested the aside needs to become a div. Easy fix thankfully 😅
marcoscaceres on 21 Apr 2021
👍2
All 2 comments

Regression. Spoke to the ARIA in HTML editors yesterday and they suggested the aside needs to become a div. Easy fix thankfully 😅
marcoscaceres on 21 Apr 2021
👍2
Closed via https://github.com/w3c/respec/pull/3471
marcoscaceres on 21 Apr 2021
Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings
Related issues

Make table rows sortable
marcoscaceres · 6Comments
Common abbr lookup
marcoscaceres · 5Comments
New API for external plugins
saschanaz · 6Comments
Some refs from HTML starting with "DOM" aren't available
noamr · 3Comments
respec2html doesn't process `preProcess` and `postProcess`
deniak · 5Comments