When a user is logged on they should a great starting home page, different from the public the page which everyone else sees sees when the click .
It must be user configurable but never to the point of block yourself in a place you an't get out of.
Idea: a summary of the public page others see down one side.
Yeah, this is important. I'm just thinking that this is something we should decouple from the server itself, that it is an app on its own. It could be distributed as a dependency of the server, but not as part of the same repo and the same npm package. That way, it could have independent evolution. What do you think about that?
So we want the front page to be an app, rather than something static.
I fully agree, but this has quite some codebase consequences for the current NSS.
I agree with @kjetilk that we should decouple the front-end part of the server from the backend, this will also give us compilation pipelines etc., solving some of our other issues. However, I don't think one should be a dependency of the other, because the server might work with multiple front-ends.
Another more radical approach is to ship the server as API-only, and to see everything as an app. But the codebase structure is totally not ready for that.
FWIW: @rubenverborgh is on the right track in my opinion.
I am thinking about the "Panes" app specifically in this context. I am probably confused but I was under the impression that the Panes app was intended to address this type of requirement.
Is that not the case?
Right. No strong opinions on the dependency argument here. In Debian package semantics, there's also "recommends", "suggests" and "enhances", pairing the latter might be better, BTW.
Also, I think "everything as an app" (EaaA hereafter) is the direction that @melvincarvalho wants to go too, if I have understood him correctly.
I think that EaaA is feasible for v.next, but not earlier. However, I can also see the urgency, so perhaps what we should look into now is a relatively light-weight but well-designed homepage for 5.0.0?
What we could do for v5, is create a new repository for the homepage (with compilation pipeline and everything), and just include a static export in the server repo for now. Or we could link it similarly to how we link solid-auth-client and mashlib.
@kjetilk no strong view. The idea originally was to develop a dashboard app. The index page was put together in a few hours as a stop gap.
OK, good! So, we triage this for 5.0.0?
Most helpful comment
So we want the front page to be an app, rather than something static.
I fully agree, but this has quite some codebase consequences for the current NSS.
I agree with @kjetilk that we should decouple the front-end part of the server from the backend, this will also give us compilation pipelines etc., solving some of our other issues. However, I don't think one should be a dependency of the other, because the server might work with multiple front-ends.
Another more radical approach is to ship the server as API-only, and to see everything as an app. But the codebase structure is totally not ready for that.