Minecraftforge: [1.13.2] Grass Doesn't Drop Seeds

[TheLimePixel]

Currently, minecraft:grass doesn't drop any seeds, while minecraft:tall_grass does.

[pxoxd]

Your way to fast xd

[Sollace]

Is the grass block really supposed to drop seeds, though?

[ghost]

Yes, it is supposed to. I tried on 1.13.2 vanilla, it does drop seeds.

[Sollace]

Huh. I've never seen it drop seeds before. It's always just given me dirt.

[pxoxd]

its the grass, and not the dirt variance we're talking about, The grass block will drop dirt, the grass and tall grass should drop seeds

[Sollace]

Oh.

Dammit, mojang, stop renaming stuff... >.>

Okay, it's tall_grass and double_tall_grass for me. XD

[ghost]

Ops, I were wrong, I looked at the wrong file

[williewillus]

just to clear things up

minecraft:grass_block is the full grass block that transforms to/from dirt. It does not drop seeds.

minecraft:grass is the one-high shrub tall grass. It should drop seeds.

minecraft:tall_grass is the two high double tall grass. It should also drop seeds.

So the issue is the second one, probably due to a patch issue because mojang renamed everything

[bs2609]

It's because Forge's seed list isn't populated, as it may be migrated to a better system (e.g. #5497).

This was already reported previously, although discussion has ended up being on #5434 for whatever reason.

In this instance, this would also suggest that tall grass doesn't use any Forge hook currently, which will need addressing.