Minecraftforge: [Feature Request] Built in OreDict for fences

[Da-Technomancer]

Basically what the title says, now that vanilla minecraft has added multiple wooden fence types Forge should probably add in some fence oreDict values (fenceWood for wooden fences and fence for all fences and walls).

[KnightMiner]

If that is added, so should oredicts for the fence gates and doors.

[Madsthunder]

And trapdoors ;)

[robotgryphon]

There are two trapdoors.. also who uses doors and fence gates in recipes?

[KnightMiner]

I've seen doors used to make wooden lockers and alike. It basically just ends up with what people want for their recipe

[Da-Technomancer]

I've seen fences used in the recipe for wooden scaffolding in IC2.

[BluGen]

The structural upgrades for the better barrels of the JABBA mod do too.

[robotgryphon]

Yes, people use fences. But I haven't seen fence gates tho. And trapdoors.

[BluGen]

In the FTB Infinity Evolved pack (1.7.10) are 15 crafting recipes that uses trapdoors and two recipes from railcraft that use fence gates. Equicalent fences, fence gates and trapdoors can't be used for this recipes, only the oak vanilla ones. It might be custom recipes for this pack, but they do not look unusual.
Please correct me if this doesn't apply to newer minecraft versions anymore.

[LexManos]

I am always against adding more things to the oredict because it's just a "Add ALL THE THINGS!" type deal. If modders want the oredict then they can add it. Have them agree on a name and they will all work together.
Thats how modders usually do it. If there is an issue defining a name Forge can come in an set the final word but the way we have it setup there shouldnt be any issue adding the same thing to the oredict multiple times, so modders can just do that. Or they could check if it exists first and dont add vanilla if they dont need to.

Typically when it comes to adding things to the oredict we don't do 1 item at a time, we do "here are 15 things that are commonly used in these mods from vanilla"

[Actuarius]

@williewillus added labels [Feature]

[stale[bot]]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had activity in a long time, and will be closed if no further activity occurs. If this issue was overlooked, forgotten, or should remain open for any other reason, please reply here to call attention to it and remove the stale status. Thank you for your contributions.

[stale[bot]]

This issue has been automatically closed because it has not had activity in a long time. Please feel free to reopen it or create a new issue.

[Madsthunder]

Actually no, 1.13 will bring trapdoors and buttons for the rest of the wood types. I think that those additions will apply to this issue in the very near future.

[KnightMiner]

It also brings the vanilla tag system which already marks doors and trapdoors

[Madsthunder]

You know what, I completely forgot about that