Microsoft-graph-docs: Fail to create calendar in calendar group with ErrorInvalidIdMalformed error code

[judithting]

Hi,

I have a problem to create a calendar in a calendar group.
Here are my test steps.

Step.1 GET me/calendarGroups , and the server responses:

{
    "@odata.context": "https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/$metadata#users('92682859-6e88-468b-be3e-33ef4e677d83')/calendarGroups",
    "value": [
        {
            "id": "AAMkADcwODlhZTMyLTY4M2EtNDJmNS1hOThlLTk4NjcwZTY5NTMxYgBGAAAAAACgynJHqMYvRIjOXZs4uNXyBwDhZkXigpZeQ7rmnw-sIOwEAAAAAAEGAADhZkXigpZeQ7rmnw-sIOwEAABwE3rvAAA=",
            "name": "我的行事曆",
            "classId": "0006f0b7-0000-0000-c000-000000000046",
            "changeKey": "4WZF4oKWXkO65p8P7CDsBAAAcBn8sA=="
        }
}

Step 2. Create a calendar in my calendar group which I get from step 1.
POST me/calendarGroups/AAMkADcwODlhZTMyLTY4M2EtNDJmNS1hOThlLTk4NjcwZTY5NTMxYgBGAAAAAACgynJHqMYvRIjOXZs4uNXyBwDhZkXigpZeQ7rmnw-sIOwEAAAAAAEGAADhZkXigpZeQ7rmnw-sIOwEAABwE3rvAAA=/calendars

Content-type: application/json

{
  "name": "name-value"
}

and then the server responses error.

{
    "error": {
        "code": "ErrorInvalidIdMalformed",
        "message": "Id is malformed.",
        "innerError": {
            "request-id": "c716830c-ef25-4f24-b5dd-e559d0b4b1eb",
            "date": "2018-02-26T05:40:41"
        }
    }
}

Could you help me to figure out this problem?
Thanks.

[judithting]

Hi,

I found this kind of calendar_groups_id will be failed after I send create calendar api.

POST me/calendarGroups/AAMkADVmMzE2MjY0LTZkOGYtNGI4MS1iNWMxLTljYzg3MWY5MWQxMQBGAAAAAABZMfR36TVMQ6yunaqZPvVRBwAF9fKWjhbKTIB6dNkgJcvkAAAAAAEGAAAF9fKWjhbKTIB6dNkgJcvkAACeapv_AAA=/calendars

with request body:

Content-type: application/json

{
  "name": "name-value"
}

and then the server response error too.

{
    "error": {
        "code": "ErrorInvalidIdMalformed",
        "message": "Id is malformed.",
        "innerError": {
            "request-id": "399da8b7-dc20-4797-bebc-15ed2bc1e0ef",
            "date": "2018-02-26T12:47:22"
        }
    }
}

[mlafleur]

Make sure you're URL Encoding the id before you're sending it over.

If your id is:

AAMkADVmMzE2MjY0LTZkOGYtNGI4MS1iNWMxLTljYzg3MWY5MWQxMQBGAAAAAABZMfR36TVMQ6yunaqZPvVRBwAF9fKWjhbKTIB6dNkgJcvkAAAAAAEGAAAF9fKWjhbKTIB6dNkgJcvkAACeapv_AAA=

You should be sending over (note that the = is encoded as %3D):

AAMkADVmMzE2MjY0LTZkOGYtNGI4MS1iNWMxLTljYzg3MWY5MWQxMQBGAAAAAABZMfR36TVMQ6yunaqZPvVRBwAF9fKWjhbKTIB6dNkgJcvkAAAAAAEGAAAF9fKWjhbKTIB6dNkgJcvkAACeapv_AAA%3D

[judithting]

Hi @mlafleur ,

Thanks for your suggestion.
I encoded the URL and send it again, but the server still responses the same error.
Besides, I also try to send the api via Graph Explorer but get the same error message no matter the URL has been encoded or not.

Not encoded

Encoded

[jasonjoh]

This is easily reproducible. I don't see any way to add calendars (either new or existing) to a calendar group via the API. Assigned @crchung-MSFT to help.

[judithting]

Hi @jasonjoh

I follow this document to create a calendar in an existing calendar group.
https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/graph/docs/api-reference/v1.0/api/calendargroup_post_calendars

I can create a calendar through the api if the calendar group id does not contain "_" or "-"; otherwise, it fails.

However, it's just my guest.
Could you help me to figure out this problem?
Thanks a lot.

[jasonjoh]

That sounds like a bug on our side, but I'll defer to @crchung-MSFT on that :)

[nvliumang]

is there any progress ? has this bug been fixed ?

[mishakogan]

any progress? Having similar issue using Graph SDK for Mail Items / Folders
@crchung-MSFT @mlafleur ^^^

[agallart]

In my case this works WITH = but not work with %3D:
https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/me/mailFolders/{id} or {folderName}/messages/{id}/move
{ "DestinationId": "{id}" }

and id is like 23JFGJOOREORJ.....=

@mishakogan @mlafleur

[jthake-msft]

@JuForan can your team help here?

[andresan21]

Hello,

any updates? It appears it's the same issues with getting childfolders from outlook.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/graph/api/mailfolder-list-childfolders?view=graph-rest-1.0&tabs=http
using the:

if we use the

GET /users/{id | userPrincipalName}/mailFolders/{id}/childFolders example returns "ID malformed".

regardless if it's encoded or not.