Mbed-os: ADR Unconfirmed Redundancy issue
mbed-os 5.13 (online compiler, revision 7482462434, mbed-os-example-lorawan) failing the ADR Nbtrans redundancy test required by European operators for LoRaWAN 1.0.2
Please check that the device is increasing the counter after DL reception as it should (see attachment)
Details:
Test
• Send ADR command with Redundancy parameter set to 3
• Try to post a downlink to check if the device stop the repetition
Check that devices effectively retransmits uplinks 3 times, with same uplink counter and same packet. A new downlink must stop the uplink repetition, frame counter must be increased.
michaburger
All 9 comments
cc @ARMmbed/mbed-os-wan
0xc0170
on 5 Jul 2019
Internal Jira reference: https://jira.arm.com/browse/MBOCUSTRIA-1396
ciarmcom
on 5 Jul 2019
“At this time, due to our prioritisation of work on customer projects, we are unable to devote the time to fix this issue. As an open source project, we welcome fixes to Mbed OS, so if would like to contribute a fix yourself then we would very much welcome that, please see our contribution guidelines here - https://os.mbed.com/docs/mbed-os/v5.13/contributing/workflow.html#contributions”
AnttiKauppila
on 13 Sep 2019
@ARMmbed/mbed-os-maintainers This can be closed
AnttiKauppila
on 13 Sep 2019
@0xc0170 I REALLY, REALLY, dislike seeing valid issues closed for a project that is open source just because the maintaining entity does not currently have the resources to look into it.
This not only discourages others outside ARM from contributing but burys problems.
@simonfordarm
loverdeg
on 14 Sep 2019
@loverdeg-ep Thanks for the feedback, I'll review these recent closures.
0xc0170
on 16 Sep 2019
Well I am currently not developing with ARM Mbed any more, I am just signaling a bug that needs to be fixed for European operators. Other wise you will never be able to make productive mass-rollouts with this stack.
michaburger
on 17 Sep 2019
@michaburger 👍
@loverdeg-ep We need to update our scripts to provide a way to distinguish "won't fix" issues as this one for instance. I'll keep this one on the list to be re-reviewed.
0xc0170
on 17 Sep 2019
@0xc0170 Back from vacation. Thanks! I like the concept of having open but wontfix items!
loverdeg
on 30 Sep 2019
Related issues
bcostm
·
4Comments
neilt6
·
4Comments
DuyTrandeLion
·
3Comments
chrissnow
·
4Comments
toyowata
·
4Comments
Most helpful comment
Well I am currently not developing with ARM Mbed any more, I am just signaling a bug that needs to be fixed for European operators. Other wise you will never be able to make productive mass-rollouts with this stack.