Material-ui-pickers: Add a simple time selection mode

Created on 5 Jun 2020  路  9Comments  路  Source: mui-org/material-ui-pickers

with material design

_for examples:_

Ant Design

chrome default time picker

TimePicker enhancement

Most helpful comment

This x1000. @oliviertassinari I am a lead designer in charge over overseeing 35 product teams. We get CONSTANT feedback on the analog clock as a time selection device in the Time and DateTime pickers. It's an _ok_ method for picking time on a mobile device. It's a terrible method for picking time on a desktop...I don't think I have ever seen anything but negative feedback on the analog clock time selection.

It's surprising how long it has taken to address this.

All 9 comments

@MaxMls Could you expand on your use case? What's wrong with the Chrome default time picker? What's wrong with the current TimePicker?

The default time picker in Chrome works only in the Chrome browser and is very bad for customization, the current TimePickeris bulky and I think it would be nice to have an alternative

Thanks for the details. I would agree that there is improvement potential. I have been keen to drop the Clock version of the time picker on desktop (keeping it for mobile) since I have first tried to use it. However, the usage of the TimePicker isn't frequent (much less than the DatePicker) hence not much a priority. I think that we will need to get more upvotes on this issue before we prioritize it.

would be nice to have alternatives, time picker isn't that rarely used olivier and indeed clock version isn't best from usability point of view.

This x1000. @oliviertassinari I am a lead designer in charge over overseeing 35 product teams. We get CONSTANT feedback on the analog clock as a time selection device in the Time and DateTime pickers. It's an _ok_ method for picking time on a mobile device. It's a terrible method for picking time on a desktop...I don't think I have ever seen anything but negative feedback on the analog clock time selection.

It's surprising how long it has taken to address this.

@lmb1987 Thanks for the confirmation, I think that we all agree, the clock is not OK on desktop, at least for the ambition we have with the component.

I couldn't agree more about the UX on the desktop! Needs to be improved. 馃憤

upvote!

Any update here? Thanks.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

nicky-dev picture nicky-dev  路  3Comments

harvitronix picture harvitronix  路  3Comments

aditya81070 picture aditya81070  路  3Comments

brett-patterson picture brett-patterson  路  3Comments

Harasz picture Harasz  路  3Comments