Mapbox-gl-js: Support extrusion heights over 65km
Hello,
I'm trying to create a 3D hexbin map, similar to the example you showed a while ago (https://www.mapbox.com/bites/00304/). I'm trying to do this at a country level rather than city level. I tried to raise the fill-extrusion-height to an appropriate level, as this is set in meters I'd need something in the region of 300+Km but I guess I'm hitting a limitation and I can really go above ~50Km. Do you think that this could be an error on my behalf or this is indeed a limitation perhaps do to the type of Integer that is used to set the fill-extrusion-height?
lcapel
All 7 comments
@lcapel yes, fill-extrusion-height uses a Uint16 type, so the maximum possible value is 65535. At the moment we don't have plans to use bigger numbers as the increase in memory usage would be substantial for what seems to be a pretty limited use case — from what I've seen so far most use cases don't come near 65535 meters.
lbud
on 13 Jan 2017
Let's keep this open — there's a chance we could add support for higher values while not sacrificing memory requirements, e.g. by introducing a multiplier spec property. That way you could control the height range at the expense of precision (e.g. have fill-extrusion-multiplier: 10 would allow going up to 655km but with 10m increments instead of 1m).
This use case seems quite common — every extrusion-based visualization that's on a bigger scale than city level (e.g. counties, countries) will need bigger values supported.
mourner
on 17 Jan 2017
Just adding that I'm making an earthquake map that would benefit from world-scale extrusions (65535 isn't enough), so the use case is fairly broad:
May be worth revisiting adding pixel-unit support for extrusions, per https://github.com/mapbox/mapbox-gl-js/issues/3385
peterqliu
on 27 Apr 2017
Is this closed? I'm still getting an error when the extrusion height exceeds 65535 in v0.40.0.
Error: layers.base-bar.paint.fill-extrusion-height.stops[1][1]: 67000 is greater than the maximum value 65535
at Function.module.exports.emitErrors (validate_style.js:10)
at e.i._validate (style_layer.js:374)
at e.i.setPaintProperty (style_layer.js:159)
at t.setPaintProperty (style.js:756)
at e.setPaintProperty (map.js:1309)
yonghah
on 17 Sep 2017
Whoops, I forgot to remove the maximum from the style specification. Fix in https://github.com/mapbox/mapbox-gl-js/pull/5320.
jfirebaugh
on 18 Sep 2017
@jfirebaugh I believe the maximum of fill-extrusion-base also needs to be removed.
yonghah
on 20 Sep 2017
@yonghah Good catch, thank you! Removing in #5338.
jfirebaugh
on 20 Sep 2017
Related issues
PBrockmann
·
3Comments
rasagy
·
3Comments
jfirebaugh
·
3Comments
foundryspatial-duncan
·
3Comments
mollymerp
·
3Comments
Most helpful comment
Let's keep this open — there's a chance we could add support for higher values while not sacrificing memory requirements, e.g. by introducing a multiplier spec property. That way you could control the height range at the expense of precision (e.g. have
fill-extrusion-multiplier: 10would allow going up to 655km but with 10m increments instead of 1m).This use case seems quite common — every extrusion-based visualization that's on a bigger scale than city level (e.g. counties, countries) will need bigger values supported.