Identityserver4.admin: Numeric Ids vs Guids

Created on 5 Dec 2018  路  6Comments  路  Source: skoruba/IdentityServer4.Admin

Great work, really appreciate it.
One suggestion, as many old timers using IS3/IS4 in real life projects I have used Guids for ids on entities and was somehow surprised in seeing that your base implemantation is instead using numeric Ids.
Of course you have provided good documentation on how to change things to support Guids, thank you for that, but, as I assume you and colleagues also have experience in IS4 I wonder what is the reason of your preferred choice.
In general i believe Guids are better also for slalability and merging of istances, and most benchmark show that in SQL Server newsequentialid() is even faster than autonumber.
Thanks again for your effort, very nice and useful.

sergio, Italy

low task

All 6 comments

@smellogrand Thanks for your suggestion, I will consider to use guid as default.

I've changed the int to string (guid) - here is preview:
https://github.com/skoruba/IdentityServer4.Admin/tree/feature/identity-default-key

Thanks, I believe this is more in line with recent patterns.
I suggest changing the wron title I inserted originally from mimeric to numeric.

thanks for your very useful development

sergio

Done on master. Please check new release.
Thanks!

Thanks my friend, you are a good guy, I will check it by tomorrow and give feedback.
Hope someday to return the courtesy vistiting you in Prague. For sure you deserve more than a good beer. I will let you choose a good restaurant.
stay well and keep up your good work, very helpful for many of us.
bye, sergio

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

ekjuanrejon picture ekjuanrejon  路  4Comments

denisisack picture denisisack  路  4Comments

saeedrahimi picture saeedrahimi  路  3Comments

maythamfahmi picture maythamfahmi  路  4Comments

gokayokutucu picture gokayokutucu  路  3Comments