Hosts: Remove Rollbar from blockers list

Created on 13 May 2020  路  10Comments  路  Source: StevenBlack/hosts

Hello,

I am reaching out to ask that you to please remove rollbar.com from your blocked list since it's a legit developer tool and not a malicious or advertising tool.

Most helpful comment

Hello Letania @letaniaferreira, Thayn茫 @izn, and Gustavo @gustavodiel.

Here is our prior discussion about Rollbar, which explains why Rollbar is presently blocked. This was not an easy call. Rollbar is an edge case and this is where we've drawn the line.

That said, I'm open to be convinced otherwise. In particular, is there a Rollbar privacy policy, or an ethical facet that we may have missed?

It's helpful to consider, this hosts list is for people who just don't want to be tracked, ad-bombed, phished, or everything else.

All 10 comments

Hello! Thank you for opening your first issue in this repo. It鈥檚 people like you who make these host files better!

I second this, Rollbar.com is a error tracking service, not a spam tool.

I'm opening a PR to remove *.rollbar.com from blacklist.

Hello Letania @letaniaferreira, Thayn茫 @izn, and Gustavo @gustavodiel.

Here is our prior discussion about Rollbar, which explains why Rollbar is presently blocked. This was not an easy call. Rollbar is an edge case and this is where we've drawn the line.

That said, I'm open to be convinced otherwise. In particular, is there a Rollbar privacy policy, or an ethical facet that we may have missed?

It's helpful to consider, this hosts list is for people who just don't want to be tracked, ad-bombed, phished, or everything else.

Thanks for your quick reply, @StevenBlack.

I think we should start a discussion about the Rollbar's Privacy Policy: https://docs.rollbar.com/docs/privacy-policy

Although, particularly, the biggest problem I see is in the hblock repository which uses your repository as a source - since this application is pre-installed on some Linux distributions (such as ArcoLinux), Rollbar's website and API are blocked "by default". I'm not sure if we should update hblock or remove from your blacklist. I'm open to suggestions.

My suggestion would be to open rollbar.com and/or www.rollbar.com and leave api.rollbar.com, as I am almost certain that every tracking is made via the api domain.
This leaves us with a good balance between accessing the service and stopping the tracking. WDYT?

If we're sure that Rollbar's tracking is made only through api.rollbar.com, I agree with @gustavodiel. :grimacing:

Thayn茫 @izn if you make this change to the PR then I'll merge it.

I will update the PR now, leaving only the api.rollbar.com entry.

Done.

Was this page helpful?
0 / 5 - 0 ratings

Related issues

beerisgood picture beerisgood  路  3Comments

node1634 picture node1634  路  3Comments

The-Compiler picture The-Compiler  路  3Comments

beerisgood picture beerisgood  路  3Comments

dhavalgoti24 picture dhavalgoti24  路  3Comments